Migration from Burma
-
Economics of migration from Burma/Myanmar -
Individual Documents
| Title: | | Myanmar Migrants to Thailand and Implications to Myanmar Development |
| Date of publication: | | October 2012 |
| Description/subject: | | "...Given the economic reform in Myanmar, which will flourish within the next five years, the key question related to outbound labour migration to Thailand (and Malaysia and Singapore) will be whether migrant workers, both skilled and less skilled, will remain in destination countries or consider returning home. In the past, average incomes of families were inadequate to meet household consumption expenditures (household income and expenditure survey in 1997). Consequently, people escaped from Myanmar to find higher incomes in Thailand. Now that economic development is in progress and labour demands for economic, social and political development in Myanmar are obvious, migrant workers’ decision to return will depend on two major conditions: political stability and democratic freedom on one hand and economic opportunities on the other hand. The political condition is important because some professionals determined to stay and work in Thailand due to a lack of democratic reform in the past. Less-skilled workers were also affected by the authoritarian regime in the form of corruption, forced labour, forced relocation and armed conflict. Both groups will have a serious consideration to return when they are assured of political stability. Myanmar people are highly attached to their homeland and always want to go back..." |
| Author/creator: | | Supang Chantavanich |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | IDE-JETRO Policy Review on Myanmar Economy No.7 |
| Format/size: | | pdf (237K) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 01 December 2012 |
|
-
Languages of migrants from Burma
Individual Documents
| Title: | | Burmese Border Guidelines - update 2007 - Burmese |
| Date of publication: | | 2007 |
| Description/subject: | | "The Burmese Border Clinical Guidelines are specifically designed to assist medics and health workers
practising along the Thailand/ Burma border. They have been adapted from the international treatment
guidelines and medical literature of the World Health Organisation (WHO) and Non-Governmental
Organisations (NGOs) that focus on common diseases present on the Thailand/ Burma border. Every
effort has been made to incorporate the experiences of the local medics and health providers who
have been working in the refugee camps and communities on the border for the last twenty years. The
language is in simple English...These guidelines should not replace clinical decision-making, but should act as an aid in confirming a
diagnosis when you already have an idea of the patient’s disease. These guidelines have been adapted
from medical reference books and are simplified for use in the context of refugee camps and peripheral
clinics on the Thailand/ Burma border, and therefore may not be appropriate for use elsewhere.
The treatment options help you to choose a therapy according to the severity of the disease and the
age of the patient. Treatment schedules mentioned in this book are just one way to cure a patient;
keep in mind that other therapies (suggested by other guidelines or new health workers) could be
used to treat your patient.
Read the TEXT for information about the disease. This tells you which signs and symptoms you
should expect, which tests you can use to make a diagnosis, which complications or signs of severity
to look for, which treatment to use and how to prevent the disease.
Read the TABLES for the medicine that you have chosen in order to find the correct dose according
to the age or weight of the patient. Here you will find contra indications and warnings for use
of medicines..." |
| Language: | | Burmese |
| Source/publisher: | | Aide Medicale Internationale |
| Format/size: | | pdf (2MB) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 22 December 2007 |
|
| Title: | | Silenced Minorities |
| Date of publication: | | August 2005 |
| Description/subject: | | Burmese ethnic minority languages are vanishing in Thailand as refugees and migrants feel pressure to assimilate...
"The language of the Lahu is soft and fluid, with long, smooth syllables that don’t interrupt the melody of the words. But nowadays the Lahu living in Thailand shy away from speaking in their mother tongue for fear that they will be branded as outsiders or will inadvertently reveal their illegal status in Thailand.
For 16 years—since his first arrival in Thailand from Burma—Win Maung, a 65-year-old ethnic Lahu man, has resisted the urge to speak Lahu outside his home. “I dare not speak my language because Thais would immediately identify me as an illegal,” says Win Maung. When he shops in Chiang Mai, he must rely on his broken Thai, a language he does not know well and prefers not to use. Win Maung holds a Thai identity card, but his documentation does not allow him to move freely throughout Thailand..." |
| Author/creator: | | Louis Reh |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "The Irrawaddy" Vol. 13, No. 8 |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 30 April 2006 |
|
-
Migrant women
Individual Documents
| Title: | | Do dreams come true? ‘Illegal’ young female Shan refugees in Northern Thailand: coping with contradicting (in)securities. |
| Date of publication: | | June 2009 |
| Description/subject: | | "...This thesis consists out of seven chapters. The next chapter on theory will address important political
and theoretical debates within the arena of displacement and refugee studies. Chapter three will
present the methodological approach taken within the research.
Chapters four and five are the data chapters of this thesis addressing various layers of insecurities
through thematic chapters. The chapters are based on the most important themes that arose during
fieldwork. How young Shan women first reacted to state terror, and the impact of this on their daily
lives, is highlighted in chapter four. Chapter five will explain what it means to be a young Shan
female, revealing the daily life practices and the influences they have on life chances and future
aspirations. Finally, I shall conclude by referring to the debates discussed within the theory chapter.
The key words of this research are displacement, young female Shan refugees, future aspirations and
human (in)security..." |
| Author/creator: | | Ursula Cats |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Masters Thesis - Social and Cultural Anthropology, Faculty of Social Sciences, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam |
| Format/size: | | pdf (4.9 - original version; 2.4 - OBL version) |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://www.burmalibrary.org/docs09/MASTER-THESIS-Final-version1-red.pdf |
| Date of entry/update: | | 15 September 2010 |
|
-
Policies towards Burmese migrants and refugees
Individual Documents
| Title: | | Displacement and disease: the Shan exodus and infectious disease implications for Thailand |
| Date of publication: | | 14 March 2008 |
| Description/subject: | | Abstract:
"Decades of neglect and abuses by the Burmese government have decimated the health of the
peoples of Burma, particularly along her eastern frontiers, overwhelmingly populated by
ethnic minorities such as the Shan. Vast areas of traditional Shan homelands have been
systematically depopulated by the Burmese military regime as part of its counter-insurgency
policy, which also employs widespread abuses of civilians by Burmese soldiers, including
rape, torture, and extrajudicial executions. These abuses, coupled with Burmese government
economic mismanagement which has further entrenched already pervasive poverty in rural
Burma, have spawned a humanitarian catastrophe, forcing hundreds of thousands of ethnic
Shan villagers to flee their homes for Thailand. In Thailand, they are denied refugee status
and its legal protections, living at constant risk for arrest and deportation. Classified as
“economic migrants,” many are forced to work in exploitative conditions, including in the
Thai sex industry, and Shan migrants often lack access to basic health services in Thailand.
Available health data on Shan migrants in Thailand already indicates that this population
bears a disproportionately high burden of infectious diseases, particularly HIV, tuberculosis,
lymphatic filariasis, and some vaccine-preventable illnesses, undermining progress made by
Thailand’s public health system in controlling such entities. The ongoing failure to address
the root political causes of migration and poor health in eastern Burma, coupled with the
many barriers to accessing health programs in Thailand by undocumented migrants,
particularly the Shan, virtually guarantees Thailand’s inability to sustainably control many
infectious disease entities, especially along her borders with Burma." |
| Author/creator: | | Voravit Suwanvanichkij |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Conflict and Health 2008, 2:4 |
| Format/size: | | pdf (170K) |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://www.conflictandhealth.com/content/2/1/4 |
| Date of entry/update: | | 09 April 2008 |
|
| Title: | | Out of Sight, Out of Mind: Thai Policy toward Burmese Refugees and Migrants |
| Date of publication: | | 25 February 2004 |
| Description/subject: | | "The report, Out of Sight, Out of Mind: Thai Policy toward Burmese Refugees, documents Thailand’s repression of refugees, asylum seekers, and migrant workers from Burma. "The Thai government is arresting and intimidating Burmese political activists living in Bangkok and along the Thai-Burmese border, harassing Burmese human rights and humanitarian groups, and deporting Burmese refugees, asylum seekers and others with a genuine fear of persecution in Burma..."
1. Introduction...
2. New Thai Policies toward Burmese Refugees and Migrants:
Broadening of Resettlement Opportunities;
Suspension of New Refugee Admissions;
The “Urban” Refugees;
Crackdown on Burmese Migrants;
Forging Friendship with Rangoon;
History of Burmese Refugees in Thailand...
3. Expulsion to Burma:
Informal Deportees Dropped at the Border;
The Holding Center at Myawaddy;
Into the Hands of the SPDC;
Profile: One of the Unlucky Ones—Former Child Soldier Deported to Burma;
Increasing Pressure on Migrants...
4. Protection Issues for Urban Refugees:-
Impacts of the Move to the Camps;
Profile: Karen Former Combatant;
Suspension of Refugee Status Determination;
Security Issues for Refugees in Bangkok...
5. Attempts to Silence Activist Refugees...
6. New Visa Rules: Screening Out the “Troublemakers”...
7. Conclusion...
8. Recommendations:
To the Royal Thai Government;
To the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR);
To Donor Governments;
To the Burmese Authorities...
9. Appendix A: Timeline of Arrests and Intimidation of Burmese Activists in 2003 (3 page pdf file)...
10. Appendix B: Timeline of Harrassments of NGOs in 2003 (2 page pdf file)...
11. Appendix C: Timeline of Arrests and Harrassment of Burmese Migrant Workers in 2003 (2 page pdf file)... |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Human Rights Watch |
| Format/size: | | pdf (244K, 1MB), html |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://hrw.org/reports/2004/thailand0204/profiles.pdf (refugee profiles)
http://hrw.org/reports/2004/thailand0204/thailand0204.pdf (printer-friendly) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 23 February 2004 |
|
| Title: | | MIGRANT WORKERS FROM BURMA AND THAILAND: POLICY REVIEW AND PROTECTION MECHANISMS |
| Date of publication: | | 21 February 2003 |
| Description/subject: | | COMMEMORATING 10 YEARS OF POLICY
GOVERNING MIGRANT WORKERS FROM BURMA...CONTENTS
A. INTRODUCTION:
Summary of Migrant Worker Policy in Thailand and Recommendations for Reform;
Policy Governing Migrant Workers in Thailand: An Examination of Policy and its Critics (Alison Vicary, Macquarie University, Sydney, Australia)...
B. MIGRANT WORKERS IN THAILAND:
Opening Remarks and Keynote Speech -
Nakorn Silap-acha,
Director of the Ministry of Labour;
Resolutions of the Alien Labour Policy Committee -
Dr. Premsak Piayura,
Chairman of the Labour Committee
House of Representatives,
Thai Rak Thai M.P for Khon Kaen;
Policy Motivations behind the Cabinet Resolutions of 2001 and 2002
- Sumsak Kanchnaborn,
Representative from the Ministry of Labour;
Migrant Worker Policy: Where to Now?
Dr. Supang Chantavanich,
Director of the Institute of Asian Studies
Chulalongkorn University;
Case Study of Migrant Labour Policy: The Textile and Garment Industry in Mae Sot -
Dr. Sirinan Kittisubsatit,
Institute for Population and Social Research,
Mahidol University;
The Problems of Migrant Workers from Burma -
Nay Min,
Migrant Workers from Burma,
Representative;
The Failure of the Thai Legal System: The Case of Ma Suu
Preeda Tongchumnun and Surapong Kongchantuk -
Law Project Coordinator Law Society of Thailand
Forum Asia Human Rights of Stateless Persons and
Ethnic Minorities Subcommittee;
Migrant Workers from Burma: The Thai Government’s Policy Confusion -
Bandit Thanchaisettawut,
NGO Researcher,
Arom Pongpa-Ngun Foundation;l
The Protection of Migrant Workers in Thailand -
Adisorn Kerdmongkol,
Thai NGO Network on Migrants and their Families in Thailand,
Thai Action Committee for Democracy in Burma (TACDB)...
C. MIGRANT WORKERS FROM THAILAND:
Overview: Thai Migrant Workers -
Dr. Supang Chantavanich,
Director of the Institute of Asian Studies,
Chulalongkorn University;
Inequality in Thailand: The Cause of Migration -
Dr. Yongyuth Chalamwong,
Research Director
Human Resources and Social Development Program,
Thai Development Research Institute (TDRI);
The Problems and Solutions for Thai Workers in Japan -
H.E. Mr. Kasit Piromya,
Ambassador of Thailand to Japan;
Human Security Issues for Thai Migrant Workers -
Salika Sorapipatana and Taksa Aura-ek,
Asian Research Centre for Migration (ARCM),
Institute of Asian Studies,
Chulalongkorn University;
Closing Speech -
Somchai Homlaor,
Secretary General,
Forum Asia Foundation...
APPENDIX 1: Workers’ Demands in a Textile and Garment Factory, Mae Sot -
Yaung Chi Oo Workers’ Association,
Information Release 24 June 2003...
APPENDIX 2: Case Summaries: Migrant Workers from Burma -
Interpretation and Translation Service (ITS) |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Burma Economic Watch (BEW) |
| Format/size: | | PDF (304.85 K) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 10 December 2010 |
|
| Title: | | Pushing Past the Definitions: Migration From Burma to Thailand |
| Date of publication: | | 19 December 2002 |
| Description/subject: | | Important, authoritative and timely report.
I. THAI GOVERNMENT CLASSIFICATION FOR PEOPLE FROM BURMA:
Temporarily Displaced; Students and Political Dissidents ; Migrants .
II. BRIEF PROFILE OF THE MIGRANTS FROM BURMA .
III REASONS FOR LEAVING BURMA :
Forced Relocations and Land Confiscation ;
Forced Labor and Portering;
War and Political Oppression;
Taxation and Loss of Livelihood;
Economic Conditions .
IV. FEAR OF RETURN.
V. RECEPTION CENTERS.
VI. CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS....
"Recent estimates indicate that up to two million people from Burma currently reside in Thailand, reflecting one of the largest migration flows in Southeast Asia. Many factors contribute to this mass exodus, but the vast majority of people leaving Burma are clearly fleeing persecution, fear and human rights abuses. While the initial reasons for leaving may be expressed in economic terms, underlying causes surface that explain the realities of their lives in Burma and their vulnerabilities upon return. Accounts given in Thailand, whether it be in the border camps, towns, cities, factories or farms, describe instances of forced relocation and confiscation of land; forced labor and portering; taxation and loss of livelihood; war and political oppression in Burma. Many of those who have fled had lived as internally displaced persons in Burma before crossing the border into Thailand. For most, it is the inability to survive or find safety in their home country that causes them to leave.
Once in Thailand, both the Royal Thai Government (RTG) and the international community have taken to classifying the people from Burma under specific categories that are at best misleading, and in the worst instances, dangerous. These categories distort the grave circumstances surrounding this migration by failing to take into account the realities that have brought people across the border. They also dictate people’s legal status within the country, the level of support and assistance that might be available to them and the degree of protection afforded them under international mechanisms. Consequently, most live in fear of deportation back into the hands of their persecutors or to the abusive environments from which they fled..." Additional keywords: IDPs, Internal displacement, displaced, refoulement. |
| Author/creator: | | Therese M. Caouette and Mary E. Pack |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Refugees International and Open Society Institute |
| Format/size: | | html (373K) pdf (748K, 2.1MB) 37 pages |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://www.ibiblio.org/obl/docs/Caouette&Pack.htm |
| Date of entry/update: | | 03 June 2003 |
|
| Title: | | Land of Guile: Migrant Workers in Thailand |
| Date of publication: | | October 2002 |
| Description/subject: | | "Thus far, the government's labor legislation has brought few benefits to Thailand's migrant work force which continues to withstand deep-seated corruption and abuse...However precarious the situation may be for migrant workers in Thailand, it will continue as long as cheap sources of labor remain a vital component for a healthy and vibrant Thai economy. The time is ripe for both the Thai and Burmese governments to implement genuine measures that would help ensure the just and dignified treatment of Burmese workers in Thailand..." |
| Author/creator: | | Tony Broadmoor |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "The Irrawaddy" vol. 10, No. 8 |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 03 June 2003 |
|
| Title: | | Come to Singapore And Leave Your Views Behind |
| Date of publication: | | August 2002 |
| Description/subject: | | "...The only type of foreigner more unwelcome in Singapore than an illegal migrant is an exiled dissident. Singapore’s intolerance of political dissent is a fact of life that is not lost on anyone who lives here. .." |
| Author/creator: | | Neil Lawrence |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "The Irrawaddy" Vol. 10, No. 6, July-August 2002 |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 03 June 2003 |
|
| Title: | | Laboring in the Lion City |
| Date of publication: | | August 2002 |
| Description/subject: | | "Burmese workers in Singapore make great sacrifices to make ends meet.
With its own economy wracked by decades of mismanagement, many Burmese workers look overseas to make their financial dreams come true. But for workers wishing to jump Burma’s sinking economic ship to go work in Singapore, they must first clear a series of legal hurdles, leaving many migrant workers wondering if making the journey is worth the effort..." |
| Author/creator: | | Moe Kyaw |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "The Irrawaddy" Vol. 10, No. 6, July-August 2002 |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 03 June 2003 |
|
| Title: | | Myanmar: Lack of Security in Counter-Insurgency Areas |
| Date of publication: | | 17 July 2002 |
| Description/subject: | | "...In February and March 2002 Amnesty International interviewed some 100 migrants from
Myanmar at seven different locations in Thailand. They were from a variety of ethnic groups,
including the Shan; Lahu; Palaung; Akha; Mon; Po and Sgaw Karen; Rakhine; and Tavoyan
ethnic minorities, and the majority Bamar (Burman) group. They originally came from the Mon,
Kayin, Shan, and Rakhine States, and Bago, Yangon and Tanintharyi Divisions.(1) What follows
below is a summary of human rights violations in some parts of eastern Myanmar during the last
18 months which migrants reported to Amnesty International. One section of the report also
examines several cases of abuses of civilians by armed opposition groups fighting against the
Myanmar military. Finally, this document describes various aspects of a Burmese migrant
worker's life in Thailand..." ADDITIONAL KEYWORDS: forced labour, refugees, land confiscation, forced
relocation, forced removal, forced resettlement, forced displacement, internal displacement, IDP, extortion, torture,
extrajudicial killings, forced conscription, child soldiers, porters, forced portering, house
destruction, eviction, Shan State, Wa, USWA, Wa resettlement, Tenasserim, abuses by armed opposition
groups. |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Amnesty International |
| Format/size: | | PDF version (126K) 48pg |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://www.amnesty.org/en/library/info/ASA16/007/2002/en
http://www.amnesty.org/en/library/asset/ASA16/007/2002/en/7471b112-d81a-11dd-9df8-936c90684588/asa1... (French) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 19 November 2010 |
|
| Title: | | Burmese Children in Thailand: Legal Aspects |
| Date of publication: | | December 2001 |
| Description/subject: | | "People from Burma have become the major group of displaced persons in Thailand. Most of them are currently being sheltered
along the Thai-Burma border, particularly in the Thai provinces of Mae Hong Son, Tak, Kanchanaburi and Ranong. It is
estimated that there are some 40,000 children from Burma under the age of 15 accompanying their parents. In addition,
thousands of unaccompanied children are driven across the border by the desperate circumstances in Burma. ..." |
| Author/creator: | | Nyo Nyo |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "Legal Issues on Burma Journal" No. 10 (Burma Lawyers' Council) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 03 June 2003 |
|
| Title: | | Burmese Migrant Workers in Thailand: Policy and Protection |
| Date of publication: | | December 2001 |
| Description/subject: | | "It is estimated that the overall number of Burmese migrants in Thailand is somewhere in between 800,000 and one million.
Cross-border migration into Thailand has steadily increased in recent years. Since the 1960s, hundreds of thousands of Thais
have gone to work abroad. Refugees from Burma, Laos and Cambodia have since filled this labour shortage in Thailand.
However, many of them are undocumented, illegal workers and thus constitute the most vulnerable section of the work force.
As illegal non-citizens, they are least protected by a national legal system. The Thai Cabinet recently announced a new policy
on migrant workers..." |
| Author/creator: | | Darunee Paisanpanichkul |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "Legal Issues on Burma Journal" No. 10 (Burma Lawyers' Council) |
| Alternate URLs: | | The original (and authoritative) version of this article may be found in http://www.ibiblio.org/obl/docs/Legal_Issues_on%20Burma_Journal_10.pdf |
| Date of entry/update: | | 03 June 2003 |
|
-
Trafficking of migrants
Individual Documents
| Title: | | The Mekong Challenge - Underpaid, Overworked and Overlooked : The realities of young migrant workers in Thailand (Volume 1) |
| Date of publication: | | 13 December 2006 |
| Description/subject: | | "...Thailand has emerged as the number one destination in cross-border trafficking of children and women. Many children and young women from Myanmar, Cambodia and Lao PDR migrate to Thailand in search of better life. Often their journey leads them to a life of exploitation. A significant percent of these young migrants work in four employment sectors; agriculture, fishing boats and fish processing, manufacturing and domestic work. While they become an integral part of the economy, they remain invisible and face exploitation. Exploitation is widespread and ranges from non-payment or underpayment of wages, a requirement to work excessive hours sometimes involving the use of hazardous equipment - to even more serious violations of forced labour and trafficking..." |
| Author/creator: | | Elaine Pearson, Sureeporn Punpuing, Aree Jampaklay, Sirinan Kittisuksathit, Aree Prohmmo |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Mekong Sub-regional Project to Combat Trafficking in Women and Children, ILO |
| Format/size: | | pdf (English - 2.5MB, 5.23 MB) |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://www.humantrafficking.org/uploads/publications/underpaid-eng-volume1.pdf |
| Date of entry/update: | | 12 April 2008 |
|
| Title: | | Trafficking on the Thai-Burma Border |
| Date of publication: | | November 2004 |
| Description/subject: | | Informal Burmese networks supply teenaged girls to customers of Thailand’s commercial sex industry. |
| Author/creator: | | Colin Baynes |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "The Irrawaddy", Vol. 12, No. 10 |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 31 January 2005 |
|
| Title: | | NO STATUS: MIGRATION, TRAFFICKING & EXPLOITATION OF WOMEN IN THAILAND |
| Date of publication: | | 14 July 2004 |
| Description/subject: | | I. Executive Summary;
II. Introduction;
III. Thailand: Background.
IV. Burma: Background.
V. Project Methodology;
VI. Findings:
Hill Tribe Women and Girls in Thailand; Burmese Migrant Women and Girls in Thailand;
VII. Law and Policy â“ Thailand;
VIII. Applicable International Human Rights Law;
IX. Law and Policy â“ United States
X. Conclusion and Expanded Recommendations..."This study was designed to provide critical insight and
remedial recommendations on the manner in which
human rights violations committed against Burmese
migrant and hill tribe women and girls in Thailand render
them vulnerable to trafficking,2 unsafe migration,
exploitative labor, and sexual exploitation and, consequently,
through these additional violations, to
HIV/AIDS. This report describes the policy failures of
the government of Thailand, despite a program widely
hailed as a model of HIV prevention for the region.
Physicians for Human Rights (PHR) findings show that
the Thai government's abdication of responsibility for
uncorrupted and nondiscriminatory law enforcement
and human rights protection has permitted ongoing violations
of human rights, including those by authorities
themselves, which have caused great harm to Burmese
and hill tribe women and girls..." |
| Author/creator: | | Karen Leiter, Ingrid Tamm, Chris Beyrer, Moh Wit, Vincent Iacopino,. Holly Burkhalter, Chen Reis. |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Physicians for Human Rights |
| Format/size: | | pdf (853K) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 19 July 2004 |
|
| Title: | | Trafficking: The Realities for Burmese Women |
| Date of publication: | | November 2003 |
| Description/subject: | | "...In 1993 Human Rights Watch published a report, A Modern Form of Slavery – Trafficking of Burmese Women and Girls into Brothels in Thailand’. The report was compiled through interviews with 30 Burmese women working in brothels in Thailand. Most were from remote rural villages in Shan state, entering Thailand via the Tachilek/Mae Sai border in Northern Thailand, and most were from peasant or agricultural labourer backgrounds. They ranged in age from 12 to 22, with the average age being 17. All but one had been lured to Thailand by the prospect of improving their economic situation. Only four knew they would be working as prostitutes and even those four had no idea what the actual work would be like. With no reliable sources available from the information-repressed vacuum that Burmese media operates in, the realities of life in Thailand are never seen. Individual laws applicable to migration and other valuable information that would allow women to make an informed choice are simply not available. The situation of deception, coercion and abuse detailed in the 1993 report appears to have changed little in the last ten years. Kidnappings of young women at the Tachilek/Mae Sai border who are then taken to work in brothels in Chiang Mai are not uncommon and the phenomenon of young women and girls being sold by relatives and forced to work as sex workers continues to this day.
But what of adult women who choose to come to Thailand as sex workers?
Women who choose to work as sex-workers need to be distinguished from women who are trafficked – as not all women working as sex-workers have been trafficked. What then defines trafficking? – for one definition there is the UN Protocol to Prevent, Suppress and Punish Trafficking in Persons, Especially women and Children, supplementing the UN Convention Against Transnational Organized Crime. This protocol covers recruitment, transportation and harbouring of trafficked persons. It also includes the various means of acquiring the trafficked person and describes various forms of exploitation..." |
| Author/creator: | | Jam Juree |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "Burma Issues" Newsletter Volume 13 , Number 11 |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 28 November 2003 |
|
| Title: | | Trafficking Report Says Burma's Military Uses Forced Labor. Also cites sexual exploitation |
| Date of publication: | | 12 June 2003 |
| Description/subject: | | "The State Department designated Burma as a Tier 3 government in its third annual Trafficking in Persons Report due to the Burmese government's lack of significant efforts to meet congressionally set standards for combating human trafficking.
The report, released June 11, faults Burma's military rulers for continued extensive use of internal forced labor.
"The military is directly involved in forced labor trafficking," the report says.
The report acknowledges that the military junta ruling Burma has taken steps to combat trafficking in persons for sexual exploitation, but it describes Burma's record as "inadequate."
"The Government of Burma does not fully comply with the minimum standards for the elimination of trafficking and is not making significant efforts to do so," the report says.
The State Department is required to report to Congress annually whether foreign governments fully meet the minimum standards set for the elimination of trafficking as detailed in the U.S. Trafficking Victims Protection Act of October 2000. Governments that are not making significant efforts to meet the standards are placed on the Tier 3 list. |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | U.S. Dept of State |
| Format/size: | | html, pdf (4.52 MB) |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://www.state.gov/g/tip/rls/tiprpt/2003/
http://www.state.gov/g/tip/rls/tiprpt/2003/21273.htm |
| Date of entry/update: | | 26 December 2010 |
|
| Title: | | MIGRATION & TRAFFICKING OF WOMEN & GIRLS (Chapter from "Gathering Strength") |
| Date of publication: | | January 2002 |
| Description/subject: | | OVERVIEW;
RESTRICTION ON WOMEN'S FREEDOM OF MOVEMENT;
REGIONAL MIGRATION;
TRAFFICKING;
SEX WORK;
DEPORTATION;
ACTIONS TO COMBAT TRAFFICKING;
FINDINGS & RECOMMENDATIONS. |
| Author/creator: | | Brenda Belak |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Images Asia |
| Format/size: | | PDF (567K) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 03 June 2003 |
|
| Title: | | Trafficking in Burmese women |
| Date of publication: | | 19 November 1999 |
| Description/subject: | | Interview by Samuel Grumiau, ICFTU Online..., 214/991116/SG, 18 November 1999 "Every year, thousands of Burmese women fall into the hands of mafias who force them into prostitution in Thailand. How is this traffic organised? Hseng Noung Lintner, an activist in the "Shan Women Action Network", an NGO that assists women from the Shan ethnic group, explains..." |
| Author/creator: | | Samuel Grumiau |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | ICFTU |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 27 July 2003 |
|
| Title: | | A MODERN FORM OF SLAVERY: |
| Date of publication: | | August 1993 |
| Description/subject: | | A substantial and important report.
""Lin Lin" was thirteen years old when she was recruited by an agent for work in Thailand. Her father took $480 from the agent with the understanding that his daughter would pay the loan back out of her earnings. The agent took "Lin Lin" to Bangkok, and three days later she was taken to the Ran Dee Prom brothel. "Lin Lin" did not know what was going on until a man came into her room and started touching her breasts and body and then forced her to have sex. For the next two years, "Lin Lin" worked in various parts of Thailand in four different brothels, all but one owned by the same family. The owners told her she would have to keep prostituting herself until she paid off her father's debt. Her clients, who often included police, paid the owner $4 each time. If she refused a client's demands, she was slapped and threatened by the owner. She worked every day except for the two days off each month she was allowed for her menstrual period. Once she had to borrow money to pay for medicine to treat a painful vaginal infection. This amount was added to her debt. On January 18, 1993 the Crime Suppression Division of the Thai police raided the brothel in which "Lin Lin" worked, and she was taken to a shelter run by a local non-governmental organization. She was fifteen years old, had spent over two years of her young life in compulsory prostitution, and tested positive for the human immunodeficiency virus or HIV.
"Lin Lin" is just one of thousands of Burmese women and girls who have been trafficked and sold into what amounts to female sexual slavery in Thailand. In the last two years, Thai NGOs estimate that at a minimum, some twenty thousand Burmese women and girls are suffering Lee's fate, or worse, and that ten thousand new recruits come in every year. They are moved from one brothel to another as the demand for new faces dictates, and often end up being sent back to Burma after a year or two to recruit their own successors..." |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Asia Watch and the Women's Rights Project (Human Rights Watch) |
| Format/size: | | html (394K) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 03 June 2003 |
|
-
Migrant Workers from Burma
-
Migrant workers from Burma in China
Individual Documents
| Title: | | Forgotten Workforce: Experiences of women migrants from Burma in Ruili, China (Burmese) |
| Date of publication: | | February 2012 |
| Description/subject: | | Executive Summary: "Burma’s continuing political repression and economic deterioration, coupled with China’s rapid growth, have caused a new phenomenon over the past few years: large-scale northward migration from Burma to China. The Yunnanese border town of Ruili (called Shweli in Burmese) has seen an estimated tenfold increase in the number of migrants from Burma since 2006, with numbers now exceeding 100,000. Formerly mainly employed in the jade, transport and sex industries, migrants are now working in a range of sectors, including domestic work, restaurants and hotels, sales, construction and manufacturing industries. Migrants are arriving from all parts of central and eastern Burma, particularly from the central dry zone, where continuing drought has deprived farmers of their traditional livelihoods. In Sagaing and Magwe, whole villages are draining of young people coming to find work in China. A large proportion of the migrants are women. During 2010 the Burmese Women’s Union (BWU) conducted in-depth interviews with 32 of these women from various work sectors. Most were from Burma’s central divisions. About half were high school graduates, and some had even graduated from university, but none had been able to find jobs inside Burma. The migrant women interviewed by BWU in Ruili revealed persistent patterns of work exploitation, occupational health and safety hazards and mistreatment by employers throughout different work sectors. A particularly dangerous kind of work being carried out by migrant women in Ruili is processing of petrified wood, imported from Mandalay Division and sold as highly valued home ornaments throughout China. In hundreds of small workshops, women are paid a pittance to sit for long hours sanding and polishing wood, using hazardous electric equipment and chemical solvents, without protective clothing or health insurance. On top of general exploitative work conditions, women also face gender discrimination, receiving lower pay than men in most sectors, no maternity leave and benefits, and suffering sexual harassment from employers. Health and safety risks are particularly high for the several hundred Burmese women working in the sex industry in Ruili and Jiegao, who are often forced to have unprotected sex, and face violence from clients, especially those who are drug users There are no existing mechanisms for foreign migrant workers to seek redress for cases of exploitation and infringement of their rights. They also forbidden from organising any workers’ committees or unions. This has occasionally caused workers’ pent-up resentment to erupt into violence against employers. There are no signs that the migration from Burma will ease in the foreseeable future. Burma’s November 2010 elections were neither free nor fair, and power remains constitutionally firmly in the hands of the military, which continues to receive the lion’s share of the national budget, while health and education needs remain critically underfunded. During 2011 the Burma Army has launched fierce new offensives against ethnic resistance groups seeking to protect their communities and environment from damaging resource exploitation. The military mismanagement at the root of Burma’s economic woes thus looks sets to continue, together with the outflow of migration to neighbouring countries, including China. Mechanisms to protect the rights of foreign migrant workers and prevent further injustices, particularly against women in China are thus urgently needed." |
| Language: | | Burmese |
| Source/publisher: | | Burmese Women's Union (BWU) |
| Format/size: | | pdf (1.8MB) |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://www.burmesewomensunion.org |
| Date of entry/update: | | 24 February 2012 |
|
| Title: | | Forgotten Workforce: Experiences of women migrants from Burma in Ruili, China (English) |
| Date of publication: | | February 2012 |
| Description/subject: | | Executive Summary:
"Burma’s continuing political repression and economic deterioration, coupled with
China’s rapid growth, have caused a new phenomenon over the past few years:
large-scale northward migration from Burma to China.
The Yunnanese border town of Ruili (called Shweli in Burmese) has seen an estimated
tenfold increase in the number of migrants from Burma since 2006, with numbers
now exceeding 100,000. Formerly mainly employed in the jade, transport and sex
industries, migrants are now working in a range of sectors, including domestic work,
restaurants and hotels, sales, construction and manufacturing industries.
Migrants are arriving from all parts of central and eastern Burma, particularly from
the central dry zone, where continuing drought has deprived farmers of their traditional
livelihoods. In Sagaing and Magwe, whole villages are draining of young people
coming to find work in China.
A large proportion of the migrants are women. During 2010 the Burmese Women’s
Union (BWU) conducted in-depth interviews with 32 of these women from various
work sectors. Most were from Burma’s central divisions. About half were high school
graduates, and some had even graduated from university, but none had been able
to find jobs inside Burma.
The migrant women interviewed by BWU in Ruili revealed persistent patterns of work
exploitation, occupational health and safety hazards and mistreatment by employers
throughout different work sectors.
A particularly dangerous kind of work being carried out by migrant women in Ruili is
processing of petrified wood, imported from Mandalay Division and sold as highly
valued home ornaments throughout China. In hundreds of small workshops, women
are paid a pittance to sit for long hours sanding and polishing wood, using hazardous
electric equipment and chemical solvents, without protective clothing or health
insurance.
On top of general exploitative work conditions, women also face gender discrimination,
receiving lower pay than men in most sectors, no maternity leave and benefits, and
suffering sexual harassment from employers.
Health and safety risks are particularly high for the several hundred Burmese women
working in the sex industry in Ruili and Jiegao, who are often forced to have
unprotected sex, and face violence from clients, especially those who are drug users
There are no existing mechanisms for foreign migrant workers to seek redress for
cases of exploitation and infringement of their rights. They also forbidden from
organising any workers’ committees or unions. This has occasionally caused workers’
pent-up resentment to erupt into violence against employers.
There are no signs that the migration from Burma will ease in the foreseeable future.
Burma’s November 2010 elections were neither free nor fair, and power remains
constitutionally firmly in the hands of the military, which continues to receive the lion’s
share of the national budget, while health and education needs remain critically
underfunded. During 2011 the Burma Army has launched fierce new offensives
against ethnic resistance groups seeking to protect their communities and environment
from damaging resource exploitation.
The military mismanagement at the root of Burma’s economic woes thus looks sets to
continue, together with the outflow of migration to neighbouring countries, including China.
Mechanisms to protect the rights of foreign migrant workers and prevent further injustices,
particularly against women in China are thus urgently needed. |
| Language: | | English and Burmese |
| Source/publisher: | | Burmese Women's Union (BWU) |
| Format/size: | | pdf (764K-English; 2.95-Burmese) |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://womenofburma.org/Report/Forgotten-workforce-Bur.pdf
http://www.burmesewomensunion.org |
| Date of entry/update: | | 24 February 2012 |
|
-
Migrant workers' registration in Thailand - Thai Government documents
Individual Documents
| Title: | | New deadline for foreign workers |
| Date of publication: | | 16 January 2013 |
| Description/subject: | | "The Cabinet yesterday gave the green light to a Labour Ministry proposal that the process of verifying the nationality of foreign migrant workers be extended until April 15, according to Labour Minister Phadermchai Sasomsap.
He said that with the relaxation of the deadline, the 266,677 workers from Myanmar, Laos and Cambodia who failed to complete the verification before the December 15 deadline could now live and work in Thailand until the new deadline..." |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "The Nation" (Thailand) |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 18 January 2013 |
|
| Title: | | Thai Cabinet Decision on Nationality Verification etc. (Burmese) |
| Date of publication: | | 19 January 2010 |
| Description/subject: | | . "Today (19th Jan 2010) at 09:00am in the Cabinet meeting room on the 2nd floor of the office of the Cabinet secretariat, Mr. Abhisit Vejjaajiva, Prime Minister of Thailand, was the Chair of the meeting of Thailand's Cabinet. Agenda Item 12: Extension of the Time Period for Nationality Verification and Granting an Amnesty to Remain in the Kingdom of Thailand to Alien Workers/Creating an Additional Committee Member for the Alien Workers Management Committee. The Cabinet agreed with the recommendations of the Ministry of Labour as follows:..." |
| Language: | | Burmese |
| Source/publisher: | | Royal Thai Government |
| Format/size: | | pdf (56K) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 10 February 2010 |
|
| Title: | | Thai Cabinet Decision on Nationality Verification etc. (English) |
| Date of publication: | | 19 January 2010 |
| Description/subject: | | Unofficial ENGLISH TRANSLATION by HRDFs Migrant Justice Programme...
"Today (19th Jan 2010) at 09:00am in the Cabinet meeting room on the 2nd floor of the office of the Cabinet secretariat, Mr. Abhisit Vejjaajiva, Prime Minister of Thailand, was the Chair of the meeting of Thailand's Cabinet.
Agenda Item 12: Extension of the Time Period for Nationality Verification and Granting an Amnesty to Remain in the Kingdom of Thailand to Alien Workers/Creating an Additional Committee Member for the Alien Workers Management Committee.
The Cabinet agreed with the recommendations of the Ministry of Labour as follows:..." |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Royal Thai Government (unofficial translation by Human Rights and Development Foundation (HRDF)) |
| Format/size: | | pdf (103K) |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://www.thaigov.go.th |
| Date of entry/update: | | 10 February 2010 |
|
| Title: | | Thai Cabinet Decision on Nationality Verification etc. (Thai original) |
| Date of publication: | | 19 January 2010 |
| Description/subject: | | "Today (19th Jan 2010) at 09:00am in the Cabinet meeting room on the 2nd floor of the office of the Cabinet secretariat, Mr. Abhisit Vejjaajiva, Prime Minister of Thailand, was the Chair of the meeting of Thailand's Cabinet. Agenda Item 12: Extension of the Time Period for Nationality Verification and Granting an Amnesty to Remain in the Kingdom of Thailand to Alien Workers/Creating an Additional Committee Member for the Alien Workers Management Committee. The Cabinet agreed with the recommendations of the Ministry of Labour as follows:..." |
| Language: | | Thai |
| Source/publisher: | | Royal Thai Government |
| Format/size: | | pdf (77K) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 10 February 2010 |
|
| Title: | | The Mekong Challenge - Employment and Protection of Migrant Workers in Thailand: National Laws/Practices versus International Labour Standards? |
| Date of publication: | | 2005 |
| Description/subject: | | Thai university professor and international law expert, Vitit Muntarbhorn, looks at the application of labour standards as they relate to migrant workers in Thailand. Professor Vitit concludes with a series of 12 recommendations for both government and non-government sectors. This publication also contains copies of all six sub-regional, bilateral, MOUs on counter trafficking and employment cooperation...
"...Migrant workers can contribute greatly to their home and destination countries, if the process is well managed and
if they are protected from abuse and exploitation. In reality, the situation is rendered complex by that fact that many
do not enter the destination countries legally. In the market of demand and supply, regrettably many are victims of
human smuggling and trafficking. Moreover, influxes of migrant workers who come without the necessary documents,
such as visas and work permits, often result in draconian measures such as deportation from the territory of the
destination countries, without adequate guarantees for their safety and dignity.
The lesson from Thailand is that to date, a closed door policy on migration from neighbouring countries has not
worked, given the porous border and Thailand's own labour market which acts as a pull factor. Wisely the country is
now moving towards a new and more open door policy: managing migration through cooperation between the
countries of origin and Thailand as a destination country, and synchronizing with Thailand's own labour market. In
2005 the country introduced a regularization process based upon registration of migrant workers and their employers,
with guarantees for basic rights, and this needs to be supported well in terms of effective implementation and
humane treatment of all workers....CONTENTS: Foreword...
Executive Summary...
1. Introduction...
2. Employment/Protection of Migrant Workers in Thailand...
3. Thai Laws/Practices...
4. International Labour Standards...
5. National Laws/Practices and International Labour Standards...
6. Directions...
7. Notes. |
| Author/creator: | | Vitit Muntarbhorn |
| Language: | | English, Thai |
| Source/publisher: | | International Labour Organisation |
| Format/size: | | pdf (563K) |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://no-trafficking.org/content/Reading_Rooms/reading_rooms_pdf/mekong%20challenge_employment%20a... |
| Date of entry/update: | | 03 May 2008 |
|
-
Migrant worker' registration in Thailand - articles/commentary
Individual Documents
| Title: | | Govt gives illegals last chance to register before crackdown |
| Date of publication: | | 14 May 2011 |
| Description/subject: | | "Illegal labourers from Cambodia, Laos and Burma will be given a last chance to report to the
government or face a tough crackdown if they continue to work without permission.
About two million workers from the three countries are estimated to have entered Thailand illegally
and they will be subject to a stricter watch, said permanent secretary for labour Somkiat Chayasriwong.
They are being told to register with branch offices of the Department of Employment from June 15 to
July 14 for the right to stay in Thailand for one year. Their accompanying children aged less than 15
will also be allowed to live with them...@ |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "Bangkok Post" |
| Format/size: | | pdf (50K) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 14 May 2011 |
|
| Title: | | Another 'last chance' for migrant workers |
| Date of publication: | | 12 May 2011 |
| Description/subject: | | "Authorities yesterday announced a "final chance" for immigration workers
to register from June 15 onwards. The registration period is expected to
last about a month. Estimates put the number of workers at 2 million,
employed by about 200,000 Thai or foreign employers..." |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "The Nation" |
| Format/size: | | pdf (80K) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 13 May 2011 |
|
| Title: | | More migrant offices to open: Abhisit ... but Myanmar says no decision made yet |
| Date of publication: | | 11 May 2011 |
| Description/subject: | | "THAILAND plans to accelerate the registration process of undocumented migrant workers from neighbouring countries, including Myanmar, Prime Minister Mr Abhisit Vejjajiva said last week..." ....."A DECISION has still not been made on whether to open two new offices in Thailand where migrant workers from Myanmar could apply for temporary passports, following discussions on the subject between the governments of Thailand and Myanmar in January, said a senior official from Special Branch under the Ministry of Home Affairs..." |
| Author/creator: | | Nyunt Win, Kyaw Hsu Mon |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "The Myanmar Times" |
| Format/size: | | pdf (95K) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 12 May 2011 |
|
| Title: | | Migration management in Thailand reaches a crossroads |
| Date of publication: | | 04 May 2011 |
| Description/subject: | | "Last Tuesday the Cabinet approved a new registration amnesty for
millions of undocumented migrants from Cambodia, Laos and Burma
working in Thailand..." |
| Author/creator: | | Andy Hall |
| Language: | | English, Thai |
| Source/publisher: | | "The Nation" |
| Format/size: | | pdf (146K) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 13 May 2011 |
|
-
Migrant Worker Remittances to Burma
Individual Documents
| Title: | | Remittances: Impact on Migrant Workers Quality of Life (Burma section) |
| Date of publication: | | October 2010 |
| Description/subject: | | "...It is clear that remittances send to Burma are both intended and utilised for the daily survival of migrant sending
families. Studies of remittance use by families in Burma show that the majority of money received is spent
on daily living expenses, followed by expenditure on housing, education and health.37 This demonstrates the
intensity of poverty within Burma and the dependency on migrant families for remittances to sustain basic survival.
Additionally one study found that a significant proportion of migrant-sending families in Burma (over
a third of those in the study) also used remittance funds for coerced payment to security officers including
military and police, demonstrating the state of insecurity and violation that families in Burma continue to live
with.38 The studies found that the majority of families in Burma were not able to use the remittance money for
income generating activities or investments, either because there was insufficient money left over after spending
on daily needs, or due to the fact that there are limited opportunities for productive investment due to weak
infrastructure and wide-spread poverty within sending communities.39 It appears that despite migration and
remittance sending over a period from three to ten years there has been no significant industry, income generation
or economic improvements within the villages and home communities of Burmese migrants in Thailand.40
These studies suggest that any local or national economic development benefit derived from remittances are
largely absent in the Burma context due to the political economy which undermines these processes..." |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | CARAM-Asia (Coordination of Action Research on AIDS & Mobility) |
| Format/size: | | pdf (312K - Burma extract; 7.6MB - full text) |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://www.burmalibrary.org/docs11/CARAM-Remittances_Report-red.pdf |
| Date of entry/update: | | 28 December 2010 |
|
| Title: | | Migrant Worker Remittances and Burma: An Economic Analysis of Survey Results |
| Date of publication: | | 2008 |
| Description/subject: | | Abstract"
In recent years great interest has awakened in the question of migrant remittances. A
phenomenon hitherto regarded as of little consequence, the potential for remittances to act
as a means for poverty alleviation and economic development has increasingly come to
enjoy a broad consensus. In the light of this, and the recognition that for many developing
countries remittances constitute a larger and more stable source of foreign exchange than
either trade, investment or aid, a vast and growing literature on the topic has emerged.
However, and notwithstanding this broad interest, there is yet to appear any major study
with respect to the question of migrant remittances to Burma.
This paper seeks to at least partially redress this void by examining the extent, nature and
pattern of remittances made by Burmese migrant workers in Thailand. Drawing upon a
survey of such workers conducted by the authors, we find that remittances to Burma are
large, disproportionately used to ensure simple survival, and are overwhelmingly realised
via informal mechanisms. The latter attributes are a direct consequence of Burma’s
dysfunctional economy, which sadly also severely limits the gains to the country that
remittances might otherwise bring.....
JEL Classification: O16, P34, Q14.....
Keywords: Remittances, Burma, Migration, Development Finance. |
| Author/creator: | | Sean Turnell, Alison Vicary and Wylie Bradford |
| Source/publisher: | | Burma Economic Watch/Economics Department Macquarie University, Sydney, Australia |
| Format/size: | | pdf (449K) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 28 November 2008 |
|
-
Migrant workers from Burma : general and mixed articles and reports
Individual Documents
| Title: | | GlobalWork, Surplus Labor, and the Precarious Economies of the Border |
| Date of publication: | | October 2011 |
| Description/subject: | | Abstract: "This paper focuses on the recent emergence of regional production networks and
border industrial zones, the labor migrations they are generating, and their consequences for
“surplus populations” in the Greater Mekong Subregion (mainland Southeast Asia). In this
region the textile and garment industry is employing increasing numbers of workers in border
areas on flexible and highly precarious work “contracts”. To understand these emergent labor
formations we focus on three scales of analysis through a case study from the Thailand–Burma
border. We focus on initiatives led by the Asia Development Bank, accompanying subregional
political groupings which aim to facilitate capital flows and trade by reducing transaction time
and cost, and a case study of labor recruitment and employment practices in one border town.
In examining these three scales, we question the value of characterizing such trans-national,
state-led, authoritarian, and racialized labor formations as neoliberal."
Keywords: precarious labor,migration, Greater Mekong Subregion, Mae Sot, border industrial
zones, racialization, textile and garment industry |
| Author/creator: | | Dennis Arnold and John Pickles |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Department of Geography, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, NC, USA; |
| Format/size: | | pdf (167K) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 09 November 2011 |
|
| Title: | | Understanding Recruitment Industry in Thailand |
| Date of publication: | | November 2010 |
| Description/subject: | | "Main objectives for this research report on Understanding Recruitment
Industry in Thailand are:
1. Study the structure, profile and characteristics of Thai
employment agencies
2. Examine the practices of licensed employment agencies in
recruiting Thai migrant workers for employment abroad
3. Explore possible ties between the employment agencies and
government officials and politicians
4. Investigate the enforcement of the labor recruitment law with
respect to employment agencies, as well as possible links to human
trafficking.
The study examined the existing 218 licensed employment agencies
in Thailand located in both Bangkok and upcountry. Through cooperation
with the Thailand Overseas Employment Administration (TOEA),
Department of Employment (DOE) and Ministry of Labor, information about
employment agencies was analyzed and categorized by target destination
country and sectors for employment opportunities..." |
| Author/creator: | | Supang Chantavanich, Samarn Laodumrongchai, Premjai Vangsiriphisal, Aungkana Kamonpetch, Pairin Makcharoen, Pattarin Kaochan |
| Language: | | English (English and Thai references) |
| Source/publisher: | | Asian Research Center for Migration, Institute of Asian Studies, Chulalongkorn University |
| Format/size: | | pdf (1MB-OBL version; 1.32MB-original ) 202 pages |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://www.burmalibrary.org/docs14/ARCM-Understanding_Recruitment_Industry_in_Thailand-red.pdf |
| Date of entry/update: | | 18 August 2012 |
|
| Title: | | Myanmar Migrant Laborers in Ranong, Thailand |
| Date of publication: | | September 2010 |
| Description/subject: | | Abstract:
"Thailand is the major destination for migrants in mainland Southeast Asia, and Myanmar (Burmese) migrants account for the dominant share. This paper sheds light on the actual working conditions and the life of Myanmar migrants in Thailand, based on our intensive survey in Ranong in southern Thailand in 2009. We found a wide range of serious problems that Myanmar migrants face in everyday life: very harsh working conditions, low income, heavy indebtedness, risk of being human-trafficking victims, harassment by the police and military (especially of sex workers), high risk of illness including malaria and HIV/AIDS and limited access to affordable medical facilities, and a poor educational environment for their children."...
Keywords: Migration, Household, Myanmar, Thailand |
| Author/creator: | | Koichi Fujita,Tamaki Endo, Ikuko Okamoto, Yoshihiro Nakanishi, Miwa Yamada |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Institute of Developing Economies, Jetro (IDE Discussion Paper No. 257) |
| Format/size: | | pdf (553K) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 06 October 2010 |
|
| Title: | | Rapid Assessment on The Impacts of the Economic Downturn on Workers in Thailand (Phase I & II) |
| Date of publication: | | September 2010 |
| Description/subject: | | Table of Contents:
Acknowledgements...
Phase I:
Introduction...
Government Policy and Gaps...
Trends and future forecast for employment during the economic crisis from
business sectors...
Impact of the Crisis on Informal Workers...
Impact of the Crisis on Formal Sector Work and Remittances to Rural
Households...
Conclusion...
References...
Appendix.....
Phase II:
Summary of findings...
.
Introduction...
Informal workers in urban settings...
.
The rural poor...
Workers in the formal sector...
Migrant workers and the unemployed...
Specific impacts on male and female formal and informal workers...
Conclusion...
Annexes. |
| Author/creator: | | Supang Chantavanich, Samarn Laodumrongchai, Mya Than, Artit Wong-a-thitikul |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Asian Research Center for Migration Institute of Asian Studies, Chulalongkorn University, Thailand |
| Format/size: | | pdf (1.06MB) |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://www.burmalibrary.org/docs14/ARCM-Rapid_Assessment.pdf |
| Date of entry/update: | | 18 August 2012 |
|
| Title: | | Hard Labor |
| Date of publication: | | March 2010 |
| Description/subject: | | The harsh conditions under which Burmese migrants are employed in Thailand are documented in an exhibition of the work of British photographer John Hulme that opens in Chiang Mai in April. |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "The Irrawaddy" Vol. 18, No. 3 |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://www2.irrawaddy.org/print_article.php?art_id=17934 |
| Date of entry/update: | | 17 March 2010 |
|
| Title: | | Abuse between borders: vulnerability for Burmese workers deported from Thailand |
| Date of publication: | | 22 February 2010 |
| Description/subject: | | "The Royal Thai Government appears poised to deport as many as 1.4 million workers that fail to
complete “nationality verification” procedures by the end of February 2010. The majority of these workers
are Burmese. Based upon extensive research conducted by KHRG and other organisations, it is likely
that many of these workers came to Thailand not out of an apolitical desire for economic opportunity, but
as a protection strategy initiated in response to the exploitative and violent abuse that drives poverty in
their home areas. Moreover, even workers who do not face abuse upon return face abuse at the
checkpoints to which Thai authorities transfer them during deportation procedures. These abuses include
taxation, forced labour, beatings, killing and rape. Incidents documented in this report took place
between November 2009 and February 2010..." |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Karen Human Rights Group (KHRG #2010-F1) |
| Format/size: | | pdf (481K) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 22 February 2010 |
|
| Title: | | Illegal Heroes and Victimless Crimes - Informal Cross-border Migration from Myanmar |
| Date of publication: | | December 2009 |
| Description/subject: | | Executive Summary:
"In the course of cross-border migration from Myanmar, many who are
involved in the migration process such as migrants, their families, money
lenders, brokers, transnational money transferors, etc., intentionally or unintentionally
maintain the status of illegality. However, with the objective to
negotiate their own way into the new livelihood space to secure their share
of development through migration, they see their exercises in maintaining
illegality as licit behavior, which is considered legitimate, given the social
context in which they live. The gap between what is considered illegal by
the state and as illicit by the people gets wider. It is easy for those who are
involved in the migration process to define the thin line between illegal and
illicit behavior – from their own social perception – which can never be identified
or recognized by the existing legal system in any country.
Strong social connections and networks of some ethnic groups that have
been in existence for a long time between Myanmar and its neighboring countries
have fueled cross-border human mobility in both directions, regardless
of legal border restrictions. Migration is often seen by the countries of
destination as a threat to national security and by the country of origin as
a problem to be solved. These negative perceptions got worse when crossborder
migration became more dynamic, taking place in various informal/
illegal forms. Most studies attempted to highlight push and pull factors of
this dynamic cross-border migration from Myanmar, as well as the living
and working conditions of Myanmar migrants living abroad and their remittances.
However, there are very few studies that shed light on the course
of cross-border migration from Myanmar from the view of migrants, their
families and their home community, and its implications on them.
Millions of Myanmar migrants are working under undesirable and vulnerable
conditions in foreign countries far away from their families. Most of
them got into such situations voluntarily, in order to improve the livelihood
of their families, and to provide education and health care for their children at
home. Although most of them are illegal migrant workers, they are far from
being criminals. They are making important sacrifices and live “borrowed
lives” in order to send money back home to help their families. They are just
ordinary people trying to make ends meet, and for their extraordinary sacrifices,
they are considered heroes by their families.
Most people in the countries of destination normally hear a single story
about illegal migrant workers. There are endless stories of illegal migrants
portraying them as people who are sneaking across the border, stealing
the jobs of local people, committing crimes, etc. Most people have been so
immersed with negative media coverage that migrants have become one
thing in their mind, the bad guys. It may not be fair if the bad behavior of few
unscrupulous illegal migrants is considered representative of the millions
of them working under very hard conditions, simply to provide bread and
butter for their families back home and contributing to increased production
and economic development in the country of destination.
Although the acts of professional traffickers – who are committing serious
crimes of human trafficking across borders that have a series of negative
social impacts, not only on trafficked victims, but also on the families of those
victims – are perceived as illicit, the acts of local brokers who facilitate voluntary
cross-border migration of ordinary people (exploring job opportunities
across the border) at a reasonable fee, and finding appropriate jobs for them
(through their social connections in the country of destination), are not considered
illicit by most local people. Far from being thought of as criminals,
their services create win-win situations and are considered essential, and
their actions – that may have flouted the state’s rules and regulations – cause
no victims.
This paper highlights the perception of each and everyone involved in the
course of cross-border migration from Myanmar in each step they, internationally
or unintentionally, maintain the status of illegality. It also attempts
to identify the implications of cross-border migration on migrants’ families
and their community in the country of origin. Interviews and questionnaire
surveys conducted in different projects in 2008 and 2009 in different places in
Myanmar and neighboring countries, coupled with qualitative and quantitative
analyses, attempt to enhance the reliability and representativeness of the
findings in this paper." |
| Author/creator: | | Winston Set Aung |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Institute for Security and Development Policy (Sweden) |
| Format/size: | | pdf (1.2MB) |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://www.isdp.eu/images/stories/isdp-main-pdf/2009_set-aung_illegal-heroes-and-victimless-crimes.... |
| Date of entry/update: | | 01 June 2011 |
|
| Title: | | Burma Human Rights Yearbook 2008 - Chapter 21: The Situation of Migrant Workers |
| Date of publication: | | 23 November 2009 |
| Description/subject: | | "Every year, around 50,000 people reportedly leave Burma in search of work elsewhere.
Estimates of the number of Burmese migrant workers who live outside Burma’s borders have
varied greatly however, and depend on whether both registered and illegal workers are taken
into account. While Burma’s Prime Minister, Thein Sein, claimed in December 2008 that a mere
46,057 Burmese migrant workers were legally employed abroad, Burma Economic Watch has
estimated that around two million migrant workers and refugees live elsewhere. In contrast,
Irrawaddy has reported that, of the estimated three million Burmese migrant workers who are
employed abroad, around half work illegally.3 In contrast to this figure, Moe Swe of the Burma
Workers’ Rights Protection Committee (BWRPC) has put the overall figure at four million. It has
also been estimated that up to ten percent of the Burmese population resides outside of Burma.
Such patterns of migration are likely to persist, as the International Organisation for Migration
(IOM) has stated that it expects the flow of Burmese migrant workers to increase in the coming
years...Many Burmese migrant workers have not fled for a single reason or because of a single event.
Rather, many have left as a result of what Andrew Bosson has described as the “cumulative
impact” of coercive measures and economic conditions, which push down families’ incomes until
they can no longer survive in their present locations.14 For instance, the Burmese junta’s
policies of forced labour, land confiscation and compulsory cropping have further impoverished
an already desperate rural population. The result, Bosson argues, has not been a dramatic or
spontaneous exodus of migrant workers and refugees, but rather a slower process of “gradual
displacement.”..." |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Human Rights Docmentation Unit (HRDU) |
| Format/size: | | pdf (1.38MB) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 06 December 2009 |
|
| Title: | | PERCEPTIONS OF BORDERS AND HUMAN MIGRATION: THE HUMAN (IN)SECURITY OF SHAN MIGRANT WORKERS IN THAILAND |
| Date of publication: | | October 2009 |
| Description/subject: | | "...While there are many prior studies to date on the internal conflicts
in Burma, these are mostly focused on the human rights situation within
the country. In addition, many previous marked studies, such as works
from Thai academics, International Organizations or the World Health
Organization, have highlighted the human securities of migrant
workers in the destination country whereby the process of migration has
already taken place. However, none of them have focused on the
phenomenon of migration in relation to perceptions of borders and human security. The lack of study addressing the influence of borders and human
securities as the key indicators to people's migration behaviour supports
the significance and relevance of this research...This research aims to understand the differences in the perceptions of
borders between the Thai government, Shan migrant workers, Thai
employers, and informal brokers, which perpetuate the flow of illegal
migration.
Due to the increasing number of illegal Shan migrant workers who
are living, producing and consuming products and services in Thailand,
or in other words, being absorbed into and continuing to contribute to
the Thai economy, it is necessary to map out a framework of borders,
human migration and human security for policy-makers to approach and
use in addressing the migration issue as a basis for future theoretical
development. A focus on the different perceptions of borders in the
migration phenomenon may lead toward a more comprehensive view of
the international migration process, particularly for ASEAN to have
more realistic border and migration policies.
Based on the purpose of the research mentioned above, my
hypothesis is as follows:
"The flow of illegal migrant workers is continuing and increasing
due to the differences in the perceptions and functions of borders
between the Thai government, Shan migrant workers, Thai employers
and informal brokers".
The actual primary data is derived from fieldwork conducted both
in Thailand and Burma. In addition, secondary data collected from
available literature was processed and reviewed in order to support the
borders approach in addressing human security and migration. Finally, a
comparative case study of Cambodian migrant workers is examined
based on fieldwork made in the Rayong province of Thailand..." |
| Author/creator: | | Ropharat Aphijanyatham |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | IRASEC - I'Institut de Recherche sur l'Asie du Sud-Est Contemporaine (Research Institute on Contemporary Southeast Asia): Carnet de l'Irasec / Occasional Paper Serie Observatoire / Observatory Series no. 01 |
| Format/size: | | pdf (1.95K) 90 pages |
| Date of entry/update: | | 04 November 2009 |
|
| Title: | | Occupational Hazard |
| Date of publication: | | February 2009 |
| Description/subject: | | "MAP Foundation, an innovative migrant workers’ support group based in Chiang Mai, has launched a short animated documentary on DVD to promote safety and health in the workplace aimed at migrant workers.
In a humorous but informative way, the 10-minute cartoon deals with the hazards that lurk in factories, construction projects and farms. The moral of the documentary is that migrant workers are particularly vulnerable to physical dangers and must take steps to protect themselves, for instance, by wearing protective clothing or by opposing reckless employers..." |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "The Irrawaddy" Vol. 17, No. 1 |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 16 February 2009 |
|
| Title: | | ROHINGYA, ASYLUM SEEKERS & MIGRANTS FROM BURMA: A HUMAN SECURITY PRIORITY FOR ASEAN |
| Date of publication: | | 30 January 2009 |
| Description/subject: | | Since October 2006, about 10,000 Rohingya have boarded boats in Bangladesh and Burma and headed for Thailand and Malaysia. The thousands of Rohingya boat people are only the tip of the iceberg. Millions of Burmese have fled the country in the past decade, with two million in Thailand alone...
ASEAN must be proactive in pressuring Burma’s military regime, the State Peace and Development Council (SPDC) to cease perpetuating the severe persecution and economic mismanagement that has been forcing millions of people to flee to neighboring countries. |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | ALTSEAN-Burma |
| Format/size: | | pdf (124K) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 03 February 2009 |
|
| Title: | | For Greener Pastures |
| Date of publication: | | October 2008 |
| Description/subject: | | "With few opportunities at home, many young Burmese look overseas for work. But before migrants can earn a dollar abroad they have to face queues, fees, bribes and sometimes danger..." |
| Author/creator: | | Aung Thet Wine |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "The Irrawaddy" Vol. 16, No. 10 |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 14 November 2008 |
|
| Title: | | Burma Human Rights Yearbook 2007 - Chapter 18: The Situation of Migrant Workers |
| Date of publication: | | September 2008 |
| Description/subject: | | "...Migration is usually a response to a combination of push and pull factors. In Burma the push factors have been economic deterioration and human rights abuses, while the pull factors have centred around the strong economies of neighbouring countries and their demands for labour. A significant proportion of Burma’s middle class continues to be attracted by the higher salaries and better standard of living on offer in countries like Singapore. However, for the large part of Burma’s population already living in poverty, the push factor becomes stronger every year and many now see migration as a question of survival. [2]
The level and extent of migration in Burma has now reached a point where it has become partially self-perpetuating. In a report for the Internal Displacement Monitoring Centre (iDMC), Andrew Bosson, explains the cycle of cause and effect behind displacement in Burma. In rural areas of Burma, people survive largely on subsistence agriculture. The initial push factors of forced labour, extortion, agricultural restrictions, land confiscation, economic sabotage and ongoing violence are often exacerbated by a reduction in numbers of farmers, which pushes more people to leave and reduces the numbers yet again. When SPDC forces or ethnic militias make demands on villages for food, money or labour the villagers have little choice and the fewer there are to share the burden the heavier it is. If a large number of people have been taken to work as porters, for example, and not enough are left to tend the farms, then the village faces starvation. The poorest often have little choice but to leave. [3] (For more information, see Chapter 1: Forced Labour and Forced Conscription and Chapter 6: Deprivation of Livelihood).
For this group migration is about finding whatever work is available. This generally means taking jobs in what is described as the “3D” category i.e. dirty, demeaning and dangerous. It also means working in sectors where national laws are ignored and international standards are considered irrelevant. Legal registration is often both difficult and expensive. It is also of limited benefit given the number of employers who confiscate their employees’ documents. Many migrants therefore live in a state of legal limbo and the constant fear of arrest and deportation. On top of all this, they also have to deal with largely negative attitudes from their host countries where migrant workers are often the scapegoat for myriad social problems..." |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Human Rights Documentation Unit (HRDU) of the NCGUB |
| Format/size: | | html; pdf (1.07MB) |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://www.burmalibrary.org/docs5/HRDU-archive/Burma%20Human%20Righ/pdf/migrants.pdf |
| Date of entry/update: | | 01 June 2011 |
|
| Title: | | A Dangerous, Difficult Life |
| Date of publication: | | May 2008 |
| Description/subject: | | The tragic deaths of 54 Burmese migrant workers highlight once again the hazards of working illegally abroad...
"THERE were 10 men lying beside me in the back of a pickup truck. Our bodies were covered with a thick plastic sheet and it was extremely hot. I couldn’t see a thing. I could only hear the sound of cars and trucks going by,” recalled Yan Naing Htun, a migrant worker who came to Thailand from Burma eight years ago, when he was just 10 years old.
Yan Naing Htun said he left the Burmese border town of Myawaddy after his father, who raised him and his sister alone, died of malaria. Accompanied by a close friend of his father, he made the journey to Bangkok because he had no way to support himself in Burma.
Burmese migrant workers take the lowest paying and most dangerous jobs in Thailand.
(Photo: The Irrawaddy)
Now, sitting in a square, featureless room that he shares with four other Burmese migrant workers in Mahachai, an industrial area on the outskirts of Bangkok, he looks frail, with sunken cheeks as colorless as the wall behind him..." |
| Author/creator: | | Violet Cho |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "The Irrawaddy" Vol. 16, No. 5 |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 01 May 2008 |
|
| Title: | | Fear Comes with the Job |
| Date of publication: | | February 2008 |
| Description/subject: | | "The grass is greener in Thailand for migrant workers, but it’s stained with blood...
Thailand offers a greener pasture for many Burmese migrant workers, but for some it can be a very dangerous place indeed.
In the middle of a September night in 2007, Thein Aung and four other Burmese laborers were taken by three Thai men from the huts where they lived at a sweet corn plantation in the village of Ban Jaidee Koh near the Thai-Burmese border town of Mae Sot.
The five Burmese were handcuffed and led to another village where the killing began. Four of the captives—Than Tun, 35, Kala Gyi, 27, Paw Oo, 28, and Naing Lin, 18—were shot in cold blood. The fifth man, Thein Aung, 58, feigned death and escaped..." |
| Author/creator: | | Shah Paung |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "The Irrawaddy" Vol. 16, No. 2 |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 27 April 2008 |
|
| Title: | | Migrants Are Not Commodities |
| Date of publication: | | February 2008 |
| Description/subject: | | "Thailand has a love-hate relationship with migrant workers...
Since the December elections in Thailand, much of the country’s politics have been in limbo until a new government takes power. Of all the policies awaiting review, the new Thai government would be wise to prioritize a policy concerning the 2 million migrant workers.
Are migrant workers a real threat to the national security of Thailand? Or are they contributing to the economic growth of the country, especially in border areas that were long ago left behind while the rest of the nation developed?
The International Labor Office’s recent report, “Thailand: Economic Contribution of Migrant Workers” by Prof Philip Martin, an expert on international migration from the University of California at Davis, stated: “The Thai labor force of 36 million in 2007 included about 5 percent or 1.8 million migrants.” The report said that last year, migrant workers contributed US $2 billion to the Thai gross domestic product, a figure nearly three times higher than in 1995. It was a clear indication of Thailand’s growing dependency on migrant labor in the 21st century..." |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "The Irrawaddy" Vol. 16, No. 2 |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 27 April 2008 |
|
| Title: | | Stop the abuse of migrant workers |
| Date of publication: | | 19 December 2007 |
| Description/subject: | | "Thais remain ignorant of the massive contribution made to our economy by foreign labourers...Not only do Thais fail to acknowledge the many positive contributions made to this country by foreign workers, but many also perpetuate prejudices against them. Thailand's lack of a coherent policy on migrant workers from neighbouring countries, who come in large numbers to do hard, physical jobs shunned by most locals, is preventing it from optimising the benefits of labour migration and protecting the rights of migrant and Thai workers. Those who benefit most in the absence of any genuine attempt to regulate the inflow of migrants from Burma, Cambodia and Laos are unscrupulous Thai employers bent on exploiting labour to maximise profits. Successive governments, including the outgoing Surayud government, have been complicit in the systematic exploitation of migrants, for failure to secure borders, and lax enforcement of laws relating to immigrants and employers who hire them..." |
| Author/creator: | | Editorial |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "The Nation" (Bangkok) |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 27 April 2008 |
|
| Title: | | Main findings and conclusions of report:"The Contribution of Migrant Workers to Thailand:" |
| Date of publication: | | 18 December 2007 |
| Description/subject: | | "...If migrants are as productive as Thai workers in each sector, their total
contribution to output should be in the order of $11 billion or about 6.2 per cent
of Thailand’s GDP. If they were less productive (say only 75% of Thai worker
output) their contribution would still be in the order of $8 billion or 5 per cent of
GDP. Migrants contribute anywhere from 7 to 10 per cent of value added in
industry, and 4 to 5 per cent of value added in agriculture...." |
| Author/creator: | | Philip Martin |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | ILO Bangkok |
| Format/size: | | pdf |
| Date of entry/update: | | 01 June 2011 |
|
| Title: | | Caught Between Two Hells |
| Date of publication: | | December 2007 |
| Description/subject: | | The Report Highlights the Situation of Women Migrant Workers in Thailand and China...Executive Summary:
Ten BWU researchers eondueted 149 in-depth interviews with migrant women and girl workers in Chiang Mai, Mae Sot, Ranong (Thailand) and Rulli (China) between November 2006-March 2007. Women working in diverse areas of work, ethnicity and age were asked to participate in the research so that the report could represent a wide range of experiences... The research highlights the atrocious day-to-day working conditions and human rights abuses encountered by migrant women and girls working in irregular situations and provides insight into the occupational hazards and harms migrants from Burma face in Thailand and China. The interviews were designed to provide women workers with a much-needed opportunity to speak their mind and assert their own "voice" regarding their work, a power that was often denied in their host countries...
The research has showed that:
. Migrant women and girl workers from Burma have very limited
work opportunities in their host countries due to their irregular
status and are often relegated to working in so-called 3Ds jobs (dirty,
dangerous and demeaning) with little or no labor rights. . Migrant women and girl workers are doubly marginalized and highly
vulnerable to abuses of their human rights due to both their lack of
legal status and their gender. Security concerns for migrant women and girl workers are grave as
they regularly experience threats of sexual harassment and violence
while working in host countries...
The BWU strongly urges the SPDC and governments of the host countries to consider migrant workers' needs and basic human rights. BWU insists that international human rights law be upheld and states work to protect migrants working in irregular settings, by protecting their human and labour rights, and by providing channels for redress when they are abused. |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Burmese Women's Union |
| Format/size: | | pdf (2.74MB) |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://www.ibiblio.org/obl/docs4/Caught_between_two_hells.pdf |
| Date of entry/update: | | 05 January 2008 |
|
| Title: | | Border Industry in Myanmar: Turning the Periphery into the Center of Growth |
| Date of publication: | | October 2007 |
| Description/subject: | | ABSTRACT:
"The Myanmar economy has not been deeply integrated into East Asia's production and distribution networks, despite its location advantages and notably abundant, reasonably well-educated, cheap labor force. Underdeveloped infrastructure, logistics in particular, and an unfavorable business and investment environment hinder it from participating in such networks in East Asia. Service link costs, for connecting production sites in Myanmar and other remote fragmented production blocks or markets, have not fallen sufficiently low to enable firms, including multi-national corporations to reduce total costs, and so the Myanmar economy has failed to attract foreign direct investments.
Border industry offers a solution. The Myanmar economy can be connected to the regional and global economy through its borders with neighboring countries, Thailand in particular, which already have logistic hubs such as deep-sea ports, airports and trunk roads. This paper examines the source of competitiveness of border industry by considering an example of the garment industry located in the Myanmar-Thai border area. Based on such analysis, we recognize the prospects of border industry and propose some policy measures to promote this on Myanmar soil."
Keywords: Myanmar (Burma), Greater Mekong Sub-region (GMS), regional cooperation, border industry, cross-border trade, migrant workers, logistics, center-periphery
JEL classification: F15, F22, J31, L67 |
| Author/creator: | | Toshihiro Kudo |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Institute of Developing Economies (IDE Discussion Paper 122) |
| Format/size: | | pdf (1.3MB) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 22 April 2008 |
|
| Title: | | Unsafe Harbor |
| Date of publication: | | September 2007 |
| Description/subject: | | Malaysia provides no protection for its refugee population...
"I’ve always thought that the lives of Burmese refugees were much the same from place to place. They’re generally unwanted, have few opportunities to better their lives and in many cases suffer unconscionable abuse.
An Irrawaddy correspondent witnesses the hardships facing migrant in Malaysia
Witnessing the appalling conditions endured by Burmese refugees in Malaysia, however, has brought their misery and lack of hope into greater focus.
During a visit to the Ampang suburb of the Malaysian capital Kuala Lumpur, a Rohingya community leader casually pointed to a group of young Burmese children playing near the small hut that served as their home.
“Look,” he said, pointing in their direction. “None of these children can read or write.”
None of the schools in Malaysia accepts refugee children from Burma, so these children are unlikely ever to learn while they remain in the country..." |
| Author/creator: | | Violet Cho |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "The Irrawaddy" Vol 15, No. 9 |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 02 May 2008 |
|
| Title: | | Burma Human Rights Yearbook 2006: The Situation of Migrant Workers |
| Date of publication: | | June 2007 |
| Description/subject: | | "...The number of registered migrant workers in the Thailand by the end of 2006 was roughly 400,000, whilst the number of undocumented migrants has been estimated as anywhere between 800,000 and two million, with those from Burma accounting for approximately 80 percent of this number, [4] with many working in the illegal, unregulated labor market, and in “3-D jobs” (dangerous, dirty and difficult) that often pay well below the minimum wage. The migrant community from Burma is comprised of a myriad of ethnic groups from across all of Burma’s 14 states and divisions, with the majority coming from the ethnic states which share a border with Thailand. Due to the combination of economic and humanitarian reasons prompting migration into Thailand, it is difficult to distinguish between economic migrants and asylum seekers. While many are forced to flee their homes in Burma due to continuing systematic human rights violations, migrants are also drawn across Thailand’s expansive border to escape Burma’s continually deteriorating economy in the hopes of benefiting from Thailand’s booming economy and constant demand for cheap labour. Regardless of the motivations perpetuating the constant flow of migrants from Burma into Thailand, the Royal Thai Government (RTG) maintains a strict and sometimes arbitrary policy on classifying those arriving from Burma as illegal immigrants with many victims of direct human rights abuses refused access to refugee camps, international humanitarian aid, and subject to deportation. Neither Thailand nor Burma are signatories to the 1990 UN International Convention on the Protection of the Rights of All Migrant Workers and Members of their Families, which provides basic human rights to those crossing international borders..." |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Human Rights Documentation Unit of the NCGUB |
| Format/size: | | pdf, html |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://burmalibrary.org/docs4/HRDU2006-CD/migrants.html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 16 April 2008 |
|
| Title: | | Lion City Lament |
| Date of publication: | | March 2007 |
| Description/subject: | | Burmese professionals earn good money in Singapore but still miss home...
"I feel I am nothing,” said Bo Bo Win—a statement that’s hard to believe in view of his successful life in Singapore.
Although he holds down a well-paid job as a senior engineer, with degrees from Burma’s best technical university and Singapore’s National University, Bo Bo Win is not a happy man.
“It’s so sad that we cannot contribute to the country where we were born and were first educated,” he says. “There’s nothing here.”
Bo Bo Win, who is in his thirties, is one of an estimated 50,000 Burmese working in the city-state, most of them educated and skilled people who have joined a brain drain that puts additional strains on Burma’s weak economy. The loss of so many young professionals also weakens the country’s middle class, which is best equipped to help reduce poverty and strengthen the economy..." |
| Author/creator: | | Kyaw Zwa Moe |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "The Irrawaddy" Vol. 15, No. 3 |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 04 May 2008 |
|
| Title: | | Malaysia Malaise |
| Date of publication: | | March 2007 |
| Description/subject: | | Burmese migrants battle bureaucracy and exploitation in their search for a new life...
"When he came to Malaysia 10 years ago, Tun Min Naing was full of hope. The 21-year-old even broke off his further education as a third-year student at a Rangoon university. His goal was to help his family survive in crisis-ridden Burma.
But Tun Min Naing’s Malaysian journey ended behind bars at the Semenyih detention camp outside Kuala Lumpur, where about 1,000 illegal immigrants wait for deportation or, in rare cases, recognition as bona fide refugees. Several hundred are Burmese, many of them registered with the UN High Commissioner for Refugees..." |
| Author/creator: | | Kyaw Zwa Moe |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "The Irrawaddy" Vol. 15, No. 3 |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 04 May 2008 |
|
| Title: | | Industrial zones in Burma and Burmese labour in Thailand |
| Date of publication: | | January 2007 |
| Description/subject: | | Conclusion:
"Massive migration of Burmese workers into Thailand affects both
countries. On one hand, it depletes the availability of skilled workers
in Burma, which is a clear loss for a developing country, while on the
other hand, Thailand benefits from such a reservoir of cheap manpower.
Burma receives the monthly remittances of its expatriate workers, but
Thai entrepreneurs capitalise on the value added to their export-oriented
productions by the work of the Burmese migrants.
Each country is aware of the size of the phenomenon and its impact
on their economy, but each reacts differently. The Myanmar junta
chooses to ignore the huge emigration taking place, because it reduces
the potential of social, if not political, demands building up within
society. The Thai government plays down the boost given to its economy
by the widespread use of cheap Burmese workers by its industries, and
prefers to play up the supposed or real social disorders said to be brought
by Burmese immigrants: increase of diseases such as malaria, tuberculosis
industrial zones in burma 181
and HIV; the drain on hospital resources to care for sick Burmese;45 the
expansion of prostitution; and murders and thefts. The dual attitude
of the Thai authorities is politically useful to hide their own social and
health shortcomings from their own population. The contribution of
migrants to the Thai economy is still unrecognised officially, although
a new vision’ towards migrants is beginning to appear in government
circles, probably out of necessity and to be in accordance with the
Economic Cooperation Strategy illustrated by the launch of the first
economic and industrial zone in Myawaddy-Mae Sot. For their part,
Burmese authorities, until now ignoring the plight of their expatriate
workers, recently realised the potential political benefits of monitoring
such a huge workforce in Thailand." |
| Author/creator: | | Guy Lubeigt |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | 2006 Burma Update Conference via Australian National University |
| Format/size: | | pdf (760K) |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://epress.anu.edu.au/myanmar/pdf/whole_book.pdf
http://epress.anu.edu.au/myanmar/pdf_instructions.html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 30 December 2008 |
|
| Title: | | Flexible Labor in the Thai-Burma Border Economy |
| Date of publication: | | 2007 |
| Description/subject: | | Capital Expansion
and Migrant Workers...
"...The research looks at the plight of Burmese migrant workers on the border between Thailand and Burma, in particular the town of Mae Sot. Mae Sot has become notorious for the amount, and severity of the human rights abuses. The research demonstrates that the changes to manufacturing, labour, and capital investment has led to a systematic erosion of labor rights. As argued in the thesis, labour rights are consistently sacrificed in order to attract and maintain investment, raising questions as to who are the primary beneficiaries of capitalist development. As Thailand and neighboring countries take further steps to increase border industrialization and development, labor standards are being pushed down both directly for the migrant workers employed in border industries, and often for domestic workers who are being forced to accept lower standards. The research examines the international economic context to the rise of Mae Sot as a manufacturing centre. It also looks at the groups involved in protecting workers rights, specifically the role of trade unions, and suggests that social and political organizing workers must be reignited in order to ensure their protection..." |
| Author/creator: | | Dennis Arnold |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Office of Human Rights Studies and Social Development, Faculty of Graduate Studies, Mahidol University (Human Rights in Asia Series) |
| Format/size: | | pdf (520K) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 16 April 2008 |
|
| Title: | | The economic contribution of migrant workers to Thailand: towards policy development (English) |
| Date of publication: | | 2007 |
| Description/subject: | | "This paper highlights the contributions of migrant workers to Thailand and recommends policies to promote economic development and decent work in both receiving and sending countries. The ILO views labour migration as a positive force that can stimulate economic growth and development in both labour-sending and labour– receiving countries, and has developed a framework of principles, guidelines and examples to ensure that labour migration contributes to decent work for all (ILO, 2004, 2006)...In 2007, migrant workers in Thailand totaled 1.8 million, comprising 5 per cent of the Thai labour force. They are mainly from Myanmar, Cambodia and Lao PDR, and are employed mostly in agriculture and fisheries, construction, manufacturing, and services such as domestic workers. They are primarily young workers, in the age group that typically pays taxes rather than receives tax-supported services. The report estimates that, in recent years, migrants have made a net contribution of about US$53 million annually to the Thai economy. The report proposes changing migration policy to make it more flexible, with separate registration procedures for different economic sectors, and placing recruitment and deployment under Memoranda of Understanding with migrant sending countries. Labour migration is a process to be managed and not a problem to be solved, argues the report. By recognizing the contributions of migrant workers to the economy and following the proposed adjustments to migration policy, the Thai government could better manage labour migration while protecting migrants." |
| Author/creator: | | Philip Martin |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | International Labour Organisation (ILO) |
| Format/size: | | pdf (518K) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 01 June 2011 |
|
| Title: | | The economic contribution of migrant workers to Thailand: towards policy development (Thai) |
| Date of publication: | | 2007 |
| Description/subject: | | This paper highlights the contributions of migrant workers to Thailand and recommends policies to promote economic development and decent work in both receiving and sending countries. The ILO views labour migration as a positive force that can stimulate economic growth and development in both labour-sending and labour– receiving countries, and has developed a framework of principles, guidelines and examples to ensure that labour migration contributes to decent work for all (ILO, 2004, 2006)...In 2007, migrant workers in Thailand totaled 1.8 million, comprising 5 per cent of the Thai labour force. They are mainly from Myanmar, Cambodia and Lao PDR, and are employed mostly in agriculture and fisheries, construction, manufacturing, and services such as domestic workers. They are primarily young workers, in the age group that typically pays taxes rather than receives tax-supported services. The report estimates that, in recent years, migrants have made a net contribution of about US$53 million annually to the Thai economy. The report proposes changing migration policy to make it more flexible, with separate registration procedures for different economic sectors, and placing recruitment and deployment under Memoranda of Understanding with migrant sending countries. Labour migration is a process to be managed and not a problem to be solved, argues the report. By recognizing the contributions of migrant workers to the economy and following the proposed adjustments to migration policy, the Thai government could better manage labour migration while protecting migrants. |
| Author/creator: | | Philip Martin |
| Language: | | Thai |
| Source/publisher: | | International Labour Organisation (ILO) |
| Format/size: | | pdf (435K) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 01 June 2011 |
|
| Title: | | Burma Human Rights Yearbook 2005: The Situation of Migrant Workers |
| Date of publication: | | July 2006 |
| Description/subject: | | "Throughout 2005 thousands of people from Burma continued to leave their country in order to seek employment abroad. Due to a range of political, economic and social factors, the population of Burma is highly mobile. Mass migration out of Burma has continued since the 1962 Ne Win military takeover of the country. The ongoing exodus represents one of the largest migration flows in Southeast Asia. It is estimated that 10 percent of Burma’s population has migrated to other countries. Most migration from Burma involves overland cross-border travel to neighboring countries, including Bangladesh and India to the west, China to the north, and Laos, Malaysia and Thailand to the east. The greatest concentration of migrant workers from Burma is in Thailand followed by Malaysia, Singapore and Japan. Accurate demographic data of migrant workers from Burma in most countries however is difficult to obtain because many are undocumented and unregistered in their destinations.
In many cases migration is the only option for those targeted by the regime and caught in the middle of military conflict, particularly those of ethnic minority groups. Systematic human rights violations such as mass forced relocation, arbitrary arrest, torture, rape, and extra judicial killings carried out by the SPDC leave no other option other then to seek refuge in other countries. Because entry into refugee camps in Thailand and Bangladesh is limited and only some are granted refugee status, many are forced to either enter the camps illegally or seek unauthorized employment. Many who have fled severe human rights abuses in Burma with valid claims to refugee status are categorized as economic migrants and therefore are vulnerable to involuntary repatriation..." |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Human Rights Documentation Unit of the NCGUB |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 16 April 2008 |
|
| Title: | | Die Lebensqualität von Migrant/innen in Thailand |
| Date of publication: | | 29 December 2005 |
| Description/subject: | | Politik und Gesetzgebung für Arbeitsmigrant/innen, Lebens- und Arbeitsbedingungen, Bildung in Thailand, Probleme der Rückkehr und Wiedereingliederung, Sicherheit, Bewegung und Reisen
keywords: migrant workers, working conditions |
| Author/creator: | | Jackie Pollock (Übersetzung von Daniel Hilbring) |
| Language: | | Deutsch, German |
| Source/publisher: | | Asienhaus Focus Asien Nr. 26 |
| Format/size: | | pdf |
| Date of entry/update: | | 20 March 2006 |
|
| Title: | | Burma Human Rights Yearbook 2004: The Situation of Migrant Workers |
| Date of publication: | | 01 October 2005 |
| Description/subject: | | "Throughout 2004, large numbers of people continued to leave Burma to seek work abroad. Approximately ten percent of Burma’s population migrates to other countries, according to a report, Migration, Needs, Issues and Responses in the Greater Mekong Subregion 2002, by the Asian Migrant Center. People leave Burma for a number of reasons. Rampant inflation, a deteriorating economy and general lack of employment and educational opportunities are factors that cause many people to emigrate. In addition to these hardships, many people living in rural areas are forced to pay heavy taxes to local officials and the military and to sell a large percentage of their crops to the government at below-market prices. The regime’s gross and continued violation of fundamental human rights resulted in the extension of U.S. trade sanctions and the institution of EU non-trade related sanctions in August 2004, placing further economic pressure on the citizens of Burma (source: World Factbook, CIA, 2004). For these reasons, many Burmese view their migration as less of a decision than an economic necessity.
Ethnic minority people living in civil war zones often have no choice about emigrating, as they are forced to flee their homes to avoid brutal campaigns of violence perpetrated against them by SPDC soldiers. Every year thousands of people flee across the border, primarily into Thailand, to escape human rights violations which include mass forced relocation, arbitrary arrest, torture, rape and extra-judicial killing. Some of these people are able to enter refugee camps in Thailand and Bangladesh. However, many of those fleeing human rights violations are not recognized as refugees by the governments of countries neighboring Burma to which they usually arrive. These individuals are left with the choice of trying to enter refugee camps illegally or else trying to survive as migrant workers.
Migration from Burma is facilitated by the fact that seven of Burma’s 14 states and divisions share borders with neighboring countries. In the west, Burma borders Bangladesh and India, in the north and northeast China, and in the east Laos, Malaysia and Thailand. In a 1999 report by Save the Children UK, Small Dreams Beyond Reach: The Lives of Migrant Children and Youth Along the Borders of China, Myanmar, and Thailand, the authors note that in the past ten years the largest flow of migrants in the Mekong region has been concentrated along the borders of China, Burma and Thailand, with Burmese people making up the largest percentage of the population migrating. The report goes on to note that while China, India, Bangladesh and Thailand have collectively reported hosting over two million Burmese migrants, the actual population of people from Burma living in these countries is likely to be much higher. However, it is extremely difficult to obtain accurate estimates as to the number of Burmese working abroad, as many are illegal, and the migrant population as a whole is highly mobile. In addition, some migrant groups are ethnically similar to indigenous populations of neighboring countries, making them difficult to identify as non-natives..." |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Human Rights Documentation Unit of the NCGUB |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 16 April 2008 |
|
| Title: | | EXPLOITATION IN GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS: BURMESE MIGRANT WORKERS IN MAE SOT, THAILAND |
| Date of publication: | | September 2005 |
| Description/subject: | | CONCLUSIONS
As outlined, the situation in Mae Sot makes it difficult for organisations to operate effectively in support of Burmese workers. In mid-2004 there were no Thailand-based organisations working specifically on labour issues in Tak. As we have shown, migrant workers are in a vulnerable situation and greater organisational and protection efforts are needed. This organisational and political weakness is in stark contrast to that of employers who enjoy the support of the state. This imbalance makes it difficult for workers to organise to protect or promote their rights. The handful of Burmese organisations attempting to assist workers is limited because of their problematic legal status in Thailand and the intimidation prevents them from operating without fear of reprisals.
Structural factors promote the exploitation and human rights violations of Burmese migrant labourers. Burmese leave Burma due to political oppression and socio-economic hardship, and subsequently have a high threshold for the difficulties they endure in Thailand. Thai authorities and employers, regardless of nationality, are eager to exploit this vulnerability in their effort to maximise profits. A lack of corporate social responsibility and adherence to corporate codes of conduct means workers at the bottom of the supply chain, in places such as Mae Sot, produce textiles and garments and other products for developed country markets in a state of constant exploitation and oppression. It is obvious that Burmese migrant workers in Thailand face a myriad of human rights issues in Thailand and Burma. Denying the freedom to organise effectively undermines any attempts by migrant workers to improve their situation.
The policy of the Thai government towards Burmese refugees and migrants is changing. Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra’s government has forged closer economic and political ties with the Burmese junta and this has involved an increasingly hard-line stance towards Burmese migrants and refugees. Some million and a half Burmese migrant workers in Thailand are now stuck between one the most brutal military dictatorships in the world, and a Thai government intent on maintaining good relations. While the Thai government trumpets “constructive engagement,” there is no doubt that the government’s attitude is driven by business interests.
It is worth noting that the traditional gap between migrant support organisations and workers, and Thai labour organisations has been reduced over the last year or so. This, in combination with greater advocacy for migrant rights – by Thailand’s Human Rights Commission, international and global trade unions, academics in Thailand and the region, governments and human and labour rights organisations both in the region and internationally – is creating space and the potential for greater transparency and respect for labour rights and adherence to labour laws and standards. It may enhance the ability of migrant workers to organise and improve work conditions, but the struggle will still be a long and difficult one. |
| Author/creator: | | Dennis Arnold, Kevin Hewison |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Journal of Contemporary Asia, Vol. 35 No. 3, 2005, pp. 319-340. |
| Format/size: | | pdf (145K) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 08 October 2005 |
|
| Title: | | Preliminary Survey Results about Burmese Migrant Workers in Thailand: State/division of origin, year of entry, minimum wages and work permits |
| Date of publication: | | September 2005 |
| Description/subject: | | 1. INTRODUCTION:
People from Burma have been entering Thailand since the Ne Win coup in 1962. Most of these people have fled civil war, hunger, poverty, unemployment and political oppression. A significant proportion of these Burmese are employed in the lower rungs of the Thai labour market. Despite the large numbers of people from Burma working in Thailand, there has been very little reliable statistical analysis undertaken in order to understand the situation faced by these people. The paucity of reliable information in this area led us to conduct a survey of about 1,400 people from Burma working in Thailand.1 The survey was undertaken between October 2003 and March 2004, in the following 12 provinces:
• Bangkok
• Singburi
• Lopburi
• Saraburi
• Tak (Mae Sot District)
• Ratchaburi
• Kanchanburi (Kanchanaburi and Sangklaburi Districts)
• Ranong (Ranong District)
• Samut Sakhon (Mahachai)
• Phetchaburi
• Chiang Mai (Chiang Mai and Fang Districts)2
• Mae Hong Son (Mae Hong Son District)...The following is a discussion of the results of a partial preliminary statistical analysis of a sample of about 1,100 of these workers with regard to their place of origin, time of arrival, income in the last 20 years, receipt of a minimum wage and their possession of a work permit.3 The analysis does not involve the estimation of population parameters and any consequent inferences about the nature of the population (though inferences about the population will be published later). Rather, the following is a statistical description of Burmese workers in Thailand, which we, argue is important given the paucity of reliable and credible work in this area. |
| Author/creator: | | Wylie Bradford & Alison Vicary |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "Burma Economic Watch" 1/2005 pp 3-25 |
| Format/size: | | pdf |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://www.econ.mq.edu.au/Econ_docs/bew/1BEW2005.pdf |
| Date of entry/update: | | 11 October 2005 |
|
| Title: | | Thailand: The Plight of Burmese Migrant Workers |
| Date of publication: | | 08 June 2005 |
| Description/subject: | | "...The material below seeks to examine some of the key issues and problems faced by Burmese migrant workers and their families, the Royal Thai Government (RTG) and the employers. These include flaws in the registration implementation process; the RTG’s obligations under international law; and the general lack of labour rights for migrant workers in Thailand, including adequate pay, living and working conditions; freedom from arbitrary arrest and deportation; and adequate health care. The report also describes those industry sectors employing migrant labour, including factories, fisheries, agriculture, and domestic and day labour. The material is based on testimonies from migrant workers, official documents and media reports...Amnesty International welcomes the initiatives which the Royal Thai Government has taken to regularize migrant labour within its borders. However it remains concerned that labour protection measures, such as payment of a minimum wage; protection from arbitrary arrest, detention, and deportation; and opportunities for migrants to seek asylum are not enforced by the government. Moreover, working and living conditions for migrant workers and members of their families fall far short of international standards. Employers, local police, and smugglers often exploit migrant workers, taking advantage of the fact that some workers are unregistered. Moreover it is extremely costly and difficult for migrants to register their labour, which is compounded by the fact that they must employed before they attempt to do so. As explained above, many of them only work seasonally making it even more difficult for them to register with the government.
Amnesty International calls on the Royal Thai Government to:..." |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Amnesty International (ASA 39/001/2005) |
| Format/size: | | html (94K) |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://burmalibrary.org/docs3/Migrant-workers2005-OO.html
http://www.amnesty.org/en/library/asset/ASA39/001/2005/en/6c36f007-d4e2-11dd-8a23-d58a49c0d652/asa3...
http://www.amnesty.org/en/library/info/ASA39/001/2005 |
| Date of entry/update: | | 19 November 2010 |
|
| Title: | | Pity the Burmese Tsunami Survivors in Thailand |
| Date of publication: | | January 2005 |
| Description/subject: | | "Burma escaped the worst ravages of the Tsunami that devastated other countries in the Indian Ocean, but Burmese migrant workers along Thailand’s western seaboard have fared poorly...Although Burma escaped the worst of the tsunami, tragically many Burmese working on Thailand’s western seaboard were swept away by the wave. Before the disaster there were 60,000 registered Burmese workers in Thailand’s six western seaboard provinces— Phang Nga, Phuket, Krabi, Ranong, Trang, and Satun—and an unknown number of illegal Burmese migrants..." |
| Author/creator: | | Aung Lwin Oo |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "The Irrawaddy" Vol. 13, No. 1 |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 10 August 2005 |
|
| Title: | | Burma Human Rights Yearbook 2003-2004: The Situation of Migrant Workers from Burma |
| Date of publication: | | December 2004 |
| Description/subject: | | "...Throughout 2003, large numbers of people continued to leave Burma to seek work abroad. Approximately ten percent of Burma’s population migrates to other countries, according to a report, Migration, Needs, Issues and Responses in the Greater Mekong Subregion 2002, by the Asian Migrant Center. People leave Burma for a number of reasons. Rampant inflation, a deteriorating economy and general lack of employment and educational opportunities are factors that cause many people to emigrate. In addition to these hardships, many people living in rural areas are forced to pay heavy taxes to local officials and the military and to sell a large percentage of their crops to the government at below-market prices. For these reasons, many Burmese view their migration as less of a decision than an economic necessity. One migrant worker who had recently arrived to Mae Sot, Thailand said, "The price of airplane and bus tickets have gone up 3 times since January first, and all the edible and household goods have also gone up." Ma Kyi, age 40, and a mother of four, continued," so I have to come here. I have never dreamed to come to Thailand. I have never thought to leave my family. My husband's income is not enough to feed the whole family," (source: "Rapprochement Continues," Irrawaddy, 14 January 2003)..."...
Background: Situation for Women Migrant Workers; Situation for Migrant Children...Burmese Migrants in Thailand: Patterns of Migration and Trafficking; Living and Working Conditions; The Memorandum of Understanding; Thai Migration Policy and Legal Registration of Migrant Workers; Deportation of Migrants; 2003 Timeline of Events for Burmese Migrants in Thailand...Burmese Migrants in Malaysia: Burmese deported after labor complaint...Burmese Migrants in Japan... Burmese Migrants in India... Burmese Migrants in Singapore |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Human Rights Documentation Unit of the NCGUB |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 15 May 2005 |
|
| Title: | | The Situation of Burmese Migrant Workers in Mae Sot, Thailand |
| Date of publication: | | September 2004 |
| Description/subject: | | CONCLUSION:
As briefly outlined, the situation in Mae Sot makes it difficult for Burmese worker
support organisations to operate effectively. As late as mid-2004 there were no
Thailand-based labour organisations or trade unions working specifically on
labour or trade union rights in Tak with an office and staff located there on a full
time basis. The workers themselves are in an extremely vulnerable situation
and greater organisational and protection efforts are needed. This
organisational and political weakness is in stark contrast to that of the
authorities, police and employers. This imbalance makes it difficult for workers
to organise to protect and promote their rights. The handful of Burmese
organisations attempting to assist workers is limited because of their
problematic legal status in Thailand and the intense pressure preventing them
from operating without fear of reprisal.
Structural factors promote the gross exploitation and human rights violations of
Burmese migrant labourers in Mae Sot. Burmese leave Burma due to political
oppression and socio-economic hardship, and subsequently have a high
threshold for difficulties they endure in Thailand. Thai authorities and employers,
regardless of nationality, are eager to exploit this vulnerability for windfall profits.
A lack of corporate social responsibility and adherence to corporate codes of
conduct means workers at the bottom of the supply chain, in places such as
Mae Sot, produce textiles and garments and other products for Northern
markets in a state of acute vulnerability.
It’s obvious that migrant workers in Thailand, particularly the Burmese, bear a
lot of pressure from nearly every direction, both in Burma and Thailand. A
myriad of human rights are abused in both systematic and random ways.
Denying the right to freedom of association and right to organise effectively
pulls out any attempts by migrant workers to improve their situation at the roots.
The policy of the Thai government towards Burmese refugees and migrants is
in the process of changing, for better or worse remains to be seen. Prime
Minister Thaksin Shinawatra’s forging of closer economic and political ties with
the Burmese government has resulted in an increasingly hard-line stance by
Thailand towards Burmese migrant workers and refugees, many of the latter
have become migrant workers. Some million and a half Burmese migrant
workers in Thailand are now stuck between one the most brutal military
dictatorship in the world, and a Thai government intent on good relations with
them, with an eye on increased revenue for businessmen operating in Thailand,
and for Thai business operating in Burma.
It is worth noting that the traditional gap between migrant support organisations
and workers, and Thai unions and labour organisations has been reduced over
the last year or so. This, in combination with greater advocacy for migrant
rights – by Thailand’s Human Rights Commission, international and global trade
unions, academics in Thailand and the region, governments and human and
labour rights organisations both in the region and internationally – is creating space and the potential for greater transparency and respect for labour rights
and adherence to labour laws and standards. It also enhances the ability of
migrant workers to organise and improve work conditions." |
| Author/creator: | | Dennis Arnold |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | The Southeast Asia Research Centre (SEARC) of the City University of Hong |
| Format/size: | | pdf (294K) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 08 October 2005 |
|
| Title: | | Burma Human Rights Yearbook 2003: The Situation of Migrant Workers |
| Date of publication: | | November 2003 |
| Description/subject: | | "Throughout 2002 large numbers of people continued to leave Burma to seek work abroad. Approximately ten percent of Burma’s population migrates to other countries, according to a report Migration, Needs, Issues and Responses in the Greater Mekong Subregion 2002, by the Asian Migrant Center. People leave Burma for a number of reasons. Rampant inflation, a deteriorating economy and general lack of employment and educational opportunities are factors that cause many people to emigrate. In addition to these hardships, many people living in rural areas are forced to pay heavy taxes to local officials and the military and to sell a large percentage of their crops to the government at below-market prices. For these reasons, many Burmese view their migration as less of a decision than an economic necessity.
Ethnic minority people living in civil war zones often have no choice about emigrating, as they are forced to flee their homes to avoid brutal campaigns of violence against them by the Burmese Military. Every year thousands of people flee across the border, primarily into Thailand, to escape these human rights violations which include mass forced relocation, arbitrary arrest, torture, rape, and extra-judicial killing. Some of these people are able to seek asylum in refugee camps in Thailand and Bangladesh, however many of those fleeing human rights violations are not recognized as refugees by the Thai and Bangladeshi Governments. These individuals are left with the choice of trying to enter refugee camps illegally or else trying to survive as migrant workers.
Migration from Burma is facilitated by the fact that 7 of Burma’s 14 States and Divisions share borders with neighboring countries. In the west, Burma borders Bangladesh and India, in the north and northeast China, and in the east Laos and Thailand. In a 1999 report by Save the Children UK, Small Dreams Beyond Reach: The Lives of Migrant Children and Youth Along the Borders of China, Myanmar, and Thailand, the authors note that in the past ten years the largest flow of migrants in the Mekong region has been concentrated along the borders of China, Burma and Thailand, with Burmese people making up the largest percentage of the population migrating. The report goes on to note that while China, India, Bangladesh and Thailand have collectively reported hosting over two million Burmese migrants, the actual population of people from Burma living in these countries is likely to be much higher. However it is extremely difficult to obtain accurate estimates as to the number of Burmese working abroad, as many are illegal, and the population as a whole is highly mobile. In addition, some migrant groups are ethnically similar to indigenous populations of neighboring countries, making them difficult to identify as non-natives..." |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Human Rights Documentation Unit of the NCGUB |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 16 April 2008 |
|
| Title: | | Burma Human Rights Yearbook 2002-03: The Situation of Migrant Workers |
| Date of publication: | | October 2003 |
| Description/subject: | | Background:
"Throughout 2002 large numbers of people continued to leave Burma to seek work abroad. Approximately ten percent of Burma’s population migrates to other countries, according to a report Migration, Needs, Issues and Responses in the Greater Mekong Subregion 2002, by the Asian Migrant Center. People leave Burma for a number of reasons. Rampant inflation, a deteriorating economy and general lack of employment and educational opportunities are factors that cause many people to emigrate. In addition to these hardships, many people living in rural areas are forced to pay heavy taxes to local officials and the military and to sell a large percentage of their crops to the government at below-market prices. For these reasons, many Burmese view their migration as less of a decision than an economic necessity.
Ethnic minority people living in civil war zones often have no choice about emigrating, as they are forced to flee their homes to avoid brutal campaigns of violence against them by the Burmese Military. Every year thousands of people flee across the border, primarily into Thailand, to escape these human rights violations which include mass forced relocation, arbitrary arrest, torture, rape, and extra-judicial killing. Some of these people are able to seek asylum in refugee camps in Thailand and Bangladesh, however many of those fleeing human rights violations are not recognized as refugees by the Thai and Bangladeshi Governments. These individuals are left with the choice of trying to enter refugee camps illegally or else trying to survive as migrant workers...Situation for Women Migrant Workers; Situation for Migrant Children... Burmese Migrants in Thailand: hai Migration Policy and Legal Registration of Migrant Workers; Working and Living Conditions; Repatriation of Migrant Workers; 2002 Timeline of Events for Burmese Migrants in Thailand...Situation of Burmese Migrants in Singapore...Situation of Burmese Migrants in Malaysia: SPDC and Malaysian Government Continue Agreement to Issue Work Permits; Five Workers Drown in Attempts to Avoid Arrest; Illegal Migrants Face Fines, Imprisonment and Whipping. |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Human Rights Documentation Unit of the NCGUB |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 15 May 2005 |
|
| Title: | | Pushing Past the Definitions: Migration From Burma to Thailand |
| Date of publication: | | 19 December 2002 |
| Description/subject: | | Important, authoritative and timely report.
I. THAI GOVERNMENT CLASSIFICATION FOR PEOPLE FROM BURMA:
Temporarily Displaced; Students and Political Dissidents ; Migrants .
II. BRIEF PROFILE OF THE MIGRANTS FROM BURMA .
III REASONS FOR LEAVING BURMA :
Forced Relocations and Land Confiscation ;
Forced Labor and Portering;
War and Political Oppression;
Taxation and Loss of Livelihood;
Economic Conditions .
IV. FEAR OF RETURN.
V. RECEPTION CENTERS.
VI. CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS....
"Recent estimates indicate that up to two million people from Burma currently reside in Thailand, reflecting one of the largest migration flows in Southeast Asia. Many factors contribute to this mass exodus, but the vast majority of people leaving Burma are clearly fleeing persecution, fear and human rights abuses. While the initial reasons for leaving may be expressed in economic terms, underlying causes surface that explain the realities of their lives in Burma and their vulnerabilities upon return. Accounts given in Thailand, whether it be in the border camps, towns, cities, factories or farms, describe instances of forced relocation and confiscation of land; forced labor and portering; taxation and loss of livelihood; war and political oppression in Burma. Many of those who have fled had lived as internally displaced persons in Burma before crossing the border into Thailand. For most, it is the inability to survive or find safety in their home country that causes them to leave.
Once in Thailand, both the Royal Thai Government (RTG) and the international community have taken to classifying the people from Burma under specific categories that are at best misleading, and in the worst instances, dangerous. These categories distort the grave circumstances surrounding this migration by failing to take into account the realities that have brought people across the border. They also dictate people’s legal status within the country, the level of support and assistance that might be available to them and the degree of protection afforded them under international mechanisms. Consequently, most live in fear of deportation back into the hands of their persecutors or to the abusive environments from which they fled..." Additional keywords: IDPs, Internal displacement, displaced, refoulement. |
| Author/creator: | | Therese M. Caouette and Mary E. Pack |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Refugees International and Open Society Institute |
| Format/size: | | html (373K) pdf (748K, 2.1MB) 37 pages |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://www.ibiblio.org/obl/docs/Caouette&Pack.htm |
| Date of entry/update: | | 03 June 2003 |
|
| Title: | | Burma Human Rights Yearbook 2001-2002: The Situation of Migrant Workers |
| Date of publication: | | September 2002 |
| Description/subject: | | "There are an estimated 1 million illegal immigrants from Burma and other neighboring countries working in Thailand. Migrant
workers from Burma come from a variety of geographical locations and ethnic groups and work in several different industries
and service sectors in Thailand. There are both push and pull factors at work when people make the decision to migrate to
Thailand. The pull factors include the close geographical location of Thailand to Burma as well as the demand in Thailand for
cheap labor. The push factors include the poor state of the Burmese economy and massive human rights violations that occur all
over the country. Many workers have come to Thailand to escape the demands for forced labor and in their home states and
divisions. In the case of the more than 300,000 Shans working in Thailand, the majority of them have fled from human rights
abuses that include forced labor, forced relocations, arbitrary arrest and rape, but are denied refugee status by Thailand and
therefore are considered illegal migrants..." |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Human Rights Documentation Unit, NCGUB |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 03 June 2003 |
|
| Title: | | Burma Human Rights Yearbook 2000: The Situation of Migrant Workers from Burma |
| Date of publication: | | October 2001 |
| Description/subject: | | "The one million Burmese migrant workers in Thailand are one of the largest migrant populations in Asia. Migrant workers from Burma come from a variety of geographical locations and ethnic groups and work in several different industries and service sectors in Thailand. There are both push and pull factors at work when people make the decision to migrate to Thailand. The pull factors include the close geographical location of Thailand to Burma as well as the demand in Thailand for cheap labor. The push factors include the poor state of the Burmese economy and massive human rights violations that occur all over the country. Many workers have come to Thailand to escape the demands for forced labor on infrastructure and other projects in their home states and divisions. In the case of the more than 100,000 Shans working in Northern Thailand, the majority of them have fled from human rights abuses that include forced labor, forced relocations, arbitrary arrest and rape, but are denied refugee status by Thailand and therefore are considered illegal migrants..." Background: Situation in Mae Sot, Thailand; Situation in Myawaddy; Time-line of the Thai authorities’ operation to repatriate Burmese migrant workers in Mae Sot, and related events in December 2000; Situation for workers in CKI Factory, Mae Sot;
Raid on factory by Thai authorities; workers arrested and beaten, one killed; Employment Conditions of CKI Factory as of December 2000... Situation for Shans in Fang District, Chiang Mai...Situation in Samut Sakon, Thailand...Situation in Mizoram State, India...Situation for illegal migrant Rohingya women in Pakistan...Partial List of Incidents...Personal Accounts...Photos of The Situation of Migrant Workers from Burma |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Human Rights Documentation Unit of the NCGUB |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 16 May 2005 |
|
| Title: | | Cycle of Suffering |
| Date of publication: | | September 2000 |
| Description/subject: | | A report on the situation for migrant women workers from Burma in Thailand, and violations of their human rights... "In the 1960s Thailand was besieged by the issues of refugees and for three to four decades this issue has come in one big circle. Today, Thailand
faces yet another issue, that of undocumented migrant workers whose visibility and problems have become more sensitive and difficult. Undocumented
labor- mostly Burmese -left their country for political reasons, or due to internal fighting and insecurity. Recent reasons are more economic. To escape hardship in their home country, they find work as unskilled laborers in three Ds- dirty- difficult and dangerous jobs in Thailand.
Unlike many other migrant labor situation where most migrants are young men, women constitute a significant segment of the approximately
one million of migrant population in Thailand. Women from Burma who migrate to Thailand, much like other people migrating
all over the world, move from their homes and families in search of job opportunities in more prosperous areas. Human rights violations in Burma often cause economic hardship. However, determining
whether people leave Burma due to the hardships they suffer as a result of human rights violations is not always easy to distinguish from purely economic difficulty. Some migrant women have stated that they left Burma solely because of economic hardship.
However, many other flee because of serious human rights violations.
Many who have fled do not have enough to eat because unpaid
forced labor under harsh conditions prevents them from earning
a living. The distinction between economic hardship and violations
of civil and political rights is not necessarily a clear one. Many of these people have been unable to make a living due to continuing unpaid forced labor and forced relocation from the homes.
With little knowledge of the country to which they are moving and working, its language and it laws, women migrating from Burma are in
vulnerable position. Labor exploitation, sexual assault by their employers and law enforcement officers, abuse of power during detention and deportation
against undocumented migrant women in Thailand are systematically
documented..." |
| Author/creator: | | Aung Myo Min |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Human Rights Documentation Unit (HRDU), Burmese Women's Union (BWU) |
| Format/size: | | pdf (887K) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 14 January 2006 |
|
-
Agricultural workers
Individual Documents
| Title: | | Home Stretch |
| Date of publication: | | October 2010 |
| Description/subject: | | Many Burmese working in Thailand’s rubber industry extend their stay indefinitely, as dreams of returning home with substantial savings prove elusive...
"With rubber plantations covering nearly four percent of its total land area, Thailand is the world’s largest producer and exporter of rubber. But achieving an output of more than three million tons of rubber each year takes more than just vast expanses of land. It also requires a huge workforce, and in Thailand, this comes largely courtesy of neighboring Burma.
Nobody knows exactly how many Burmese work in Thailand’s rubber plantations, but it is generally acknowledged that the industry couldn’t survive without them. Tapping the trees and harvesting the latex to make sheets of raw rubber is labor-intensive work, demanding full attention both night and day. It’s not a job that appeals to many Thais, but Burma’s crippled economy means that Thailand’s rubber plantations have no shortage of ready and willing workers..." |
| Author/creator: | | Kyaw Thein Kha |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "The Irrawaddy" Vol. 18, No. 10 |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 22 July 2012 |
|
| Title: | | The Mekong Challenge - Underpaid, Overworked and Overlooked: The realities of young migrant workers in Thailand: Vol. 2 (1) - The Agriculture Sector |
| Date of publication: | | 13 December 2006 |
| Description/subject: | | Conclusions:
4.1 Indications of labour exploitation
Although forced labour is negligible in Nakhon
Pathom's agriculture sector, migrant workers faced
several forms of labour exploitation, particularly a lack
of freedom of movement, and regular days off. Also,
many were not in possession of their identification
documents, while they do not receive paid leave...
4.2 Legal status and registration
Although the registration of workers provides some
legal protection and minimizes the exploitation
of migrant workers, over a third of workers in
agriculture are not registered. Approximately
two thirds of registered workers who had their
registration costs paid by the employers were in effect
bonded labour and were required to pay back the
costs via deductions from their wages. Nonetheless,
the majority of workers expressed positive attitudes
towards registration, particularly with regard to job
security, safety and health insurance. A lack of time
to register and lack of information regarding the
registration process were the main reasons why some
migrants did not register...
4.3 Working conditions
The challenges facing migrants in terms of working
conditions included very low pay, restricted freedom
of movement, long working hours without overtime
pay and not having possession of their original ID
documents. The average daily payment of 100-
150 baht per day for agricultural workers is below
the minimum wage. Low wages is one reason why
migrant workers switch farms in search of higher
wages. A high turnover of workers is of great concern
amongst employers. Yet perhaps if they were willing
to pay rates equal to or above the minimum wage,
the migrant workers would not be in such a hurry
to leave.
Nearly all migrant workers live on the site of
their workplace. Workers are isolated from the
local community and seldom integrate with the
community. None of the employers speak the
language of their migrant workers and at the same
time the majority of workers have little knowledge
of Thai. However, given the nature of farm work,
there seems little that can be done in this regard,
except perhaps consider more mobile services, which
could visit migrant workers living on farms...
4.4 Employers' attitudes
Some negative attitudes towards migrant workers
exist among employers. Well over two thirds felt
migrant workers should be locked up at night to
prevent them escaping. This view was particularly
prevalent among by livestock farmers...
4.5 Support mechanisms
Social networks play a significant role in terms of
support for migrant workers in the agricultural
sector, and family and friends provide this. More
than two thirds turn to their relatives when facing
problems or when they are in need of healthcare.
This reflects the fact that most child migrant
workers reside with their relatives or parents. None
of the workers referred to NGO staff for support.
The only chance workers had to make contact with
people was with government officials from the MOL
during the registration period. Monks or religious
leaders and employers were relatively important to
the workers. The fact that child workers rely on their
social network because they are more likely to live
with family and friends on site could perhaps help
safeguard them from exploitation in this sector...
4.6 Child labour
Under Thai law, children under the age of 15 are not
permitted to work. Although a few were interviewed,
the agriculture sector in Nakhon Pathom province
employs a greater number of children aged 15 and
up. Employers seem to regard children as being
more obedient. Children under the age of 15 were
all unregistered and underpaid when compared with
workers in other age groups. The violation of the law
and exploitation of child labour requires particular
attention. |
| Language: | | English, Thai |
| Source/publisher: | | International Labour Organisation |
| Format/size: | | pdf (English - 354K; Thai - 369K) |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://www.ilo.org/public/english/region/asro/bangkok/child/trafficking/downloads/vol2-agriculture-... |
| Date of entry/update: | | 03 May 2008 |
|
-
Child workers
Individual Documents
| Title: | | FEELING SMALL IN ANOTHER PERSON’S COUNTRY - The situation of Burmese migrant children in Mae Sot Thailand |
| Date of publication: | | February 2009 |
| Description/subject: | | "...There are an estimated 200,000 Burmese children living in Thailand, many of whom are working, with 20% of the migrant workforce thought to consist of children aged 15 to 17 years of age. It was
seen to be a standard practice for parents to send children out to work, especially once they have
reached the age of 13 years and seen to be physically capable of bringing in extra income for the
family. Children may voluntarily leave or be taken out of school to work alongside their parents in the
factory or fields, as domestics or as service workers in shops and restaurants. Researchers have found
that children working in Mae Sot factories and the agricultural area are subject to the worst forms of
child labour, working long hours and being exposed to hazardous chemicals and conditions that are in
direct violation of Thai labour law. The difficulty of obtaining registration and the work permit makes for a tenuous existence. Consequently, young people can be coerced or forced into bad
employment situations...
As parent’s lives are consumed by the need to work and make money, children can be denied the love,
care and guidance essential to their healthy growth and development and may be separated from or
even abandoned by parents. Some parents abuse and exploit their children by telling them not to come
back home if they cannot earn a fixed amount per day. Consequently these children go out on the
streets looking for daily work to survive; this can include begging, collecting recyclable rubbish and
carrying heavy loads. This pressure is seen to change the moral character of children with some
turning to stealing. Children who are unemployed, neglected, abandoned, or orphaned can end up
permanently on the streets. Being out of school and on the streets increases the risk of being trafficked
and recruitment by gangs, who physically threaten and may even kill children who try to escape...
Statelessness is a real risk for children who are unable to receive identity registration in Burma and
for those born in Thailand of migrants, especially unregistered parents. Despite the ratification of
conventions, such as the United Nation’s Convention on the Rights of the Child 1989 (CRC), and the
International Convention of Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) that stipulate birth registration of all
children born in Thailand, in reality only registered migrants who hold a work permit can register
their child’s birth. A change in the Civil Registration Act, effective from the 23rd August 2008, will
allow all children born on Thai soil, regardless of their status, to register their births and obtain a birth
certificate; however it remains to be seen how this will be implemented. In the meantime the
Committee for Promotion and Protection of Child Rights (Burma) (CPPCR), a Burmese CBO
established in 2002, provides a registration service for children from Burma that in some cases, has
been recognized by some Thai schools and the United Nations High Commission for Refugees
(UNHCR)..." |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Committee for Promotion and Protection of Child Rights (Burma) |
| Format/size: | | pdf (3.4MB) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 23 November 2009 |
|
| Title: | | The Mekong Challenge - Underpaid, Overworked and Overlooked : The realities of young migrant workers in Thailand (Volume 1) |
| Date of publication: | | 13 December 2006 |
| Description/subject: | | "...Thailand has emerged as the number one destination in cross-border trafficking of children and women. Many children and young women from Myanmar, Cambodia and Lao PDR migrate to Thailand in search of better life. Often their journey leads them to a life of exploitation. A significant percent of these young migrants work in four employment sectors; agriculture, fishing boats and fish processing, manufacturing and domestic work. While they become an integral part of the economy, they remain invisible and face exploitation. Exploitation is widespread and ranges from non-payment or underpayment of wages, a requirement to work excessive hours sometimes involving the use of hazardous equipment - to even more serious violations of forced labour and trafficking..." |
| Author/creator: | | Elaine Pearson, Sureeporn Punpuing, Aree Jampaklay, Sirinan Kittisuksathit, Aree Prohmmo |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Mekong Sub-regional Project to Combat Trafficking in Women and Children, ILO |
| Format/size: | | pdf (English - 2.5MB, 5.23 MB) |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://www.humantrafficking.org/uploads/publications/underpaid-eng-volume1.pdf |
| Date of entry/update: | | 12 April 2008 |
|
| Title: | | The Mekong Challenge - Underpaid, Overworked and Overlooked: The realities of young migrant workers in Thailand: Vol. 2 (1) - The Agriculture Sector |
| Date of publication: | | 13 December 2006 |
| Description/subject: | | Conclusions:
4.1 Indications of labour exploitation
Although forced labour is negligible in Nakhon
Pathom's agriculture sector, migrant workers faced
several forms of labour exploitation, particularly a lack
of freedom of movement, and regular days off. Also,
many were not in possession of their identification
documents, while they do not receive paid leave...
4.2 Legal status and registration
Although the registration of workers provides some
legal protection and minimizes the exploitation
of migrant workers, over a third of workers in
agriculture are not registered. Approximately
two thirds of registered workers who had their
registration costs paid by the employers were in effect
bonded labour and were required to pay back the
costs via deductions from their wages. Nonetheless,
the majority of workers expressed positive attitudes
towards registration, particularly with regard to job
security, safety and health insurance. A lack of time
to register and lack of information regarding the
registration process were the main reasons why some
migrants did not register...
4.3 Working conditions
The challenges facing migrants in terms of working
conditions included very low pay, restricted freedom
of movement, long working hours without overtime
pay and not having possession of their original ID
documents. The average daily payment of 100-
150 baht per day for agricultural workers is below
the minimum wage. Low wages is one reason why
migrant workers switch farms in search of higher
wages. A high turnover of workers is of great concern
amongst employers. Yet perhaps if they were willing
to pay rates equal to or above the minimum wage,
the migrant workers would not be in such a hurry
to leave.
Nearly all migrant workers live on the site of
their workplace. Workers are isolated from the
local community and seldom integrate with the
community. None of the employers speak the
language of their migrant workers and at the same
time the majority of workers have little knowledge
of Thai. However, given the nature of farm work,
there seems little that can be done in this regard,
except perhaps consider more mobile services, which
could visit migrant workers living on farms...
4.4 Employers' attitudes
Some negative attitudes towards migrant workers
exist among employers. Well over two thirds felt
migrant workers should be locked up at night to
prevent them escaping. This view was particularly
prevalent among by livestock farmers...
4.5 Support mechanisms
Social networks play a significant role in terms of
support for migrant workers in the agricultural
sector, and family and friends provide this. More
than two thirds turn to their relatives when facing
problems or when they are in need of healthcare.
This reflects the fact that most child migrant
workers reside with their relatives or parents. None
of the workers referred to NGO staff for support.
The only chance workers had to make contact with
people was with government officials from the MOL
during the registration period. Monks or religious
leaders and employers were relatively important to
the workers. The fact that child workers rely on their
social network because they are more likely to live
with family and friends on site could perhaps help
safeguard them from exploitation in this sector...
4.6 Child labour
Under Thai law, children under the age of 15 are not
permitted to work. Although a few were interviewed,
the agriculture sector in Nakhon Pathom province
employs a greater number of children aged 15 and
up. Employers seem to regard children as being
more obedient. Children under the age of 15 were
all unregistered and underpaid when compared with
workers in other age groups. The violation of the law
and exploitation of child labour requires particular
attention. |
| Language: | | English, Thai |
| Source/publisher: | | International Labour Organisation |
| Format/size: | | pdf (English - 354K; Thai - 369K) |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://www.ilo.org/public/english/region/asro/bangkok/child/trafficking/downloads/vol2-agriculture-... |
| Date of entry/update: | | 03 May 2008 |
|
| Title: | | The Mekong Challenge - Underpaid, Overworked and Overlooked: The realities of young migrant workers in Thailand: Vol. 2 (2) - The Domestic Work Sector |
| Date of publication: | | 13 December 2006 |
| Description/subject: | | Conclusions:
4.1 Indications of labour exploitation
The findings illustrate a clear pattern of severe
labour exploitation of migrant domestic workers,
and in various cases evidence of forced labour.
Domestic workers surveyed in Chiang Mai and Mae
Sot reported being locked in the house unable to
readily communicate or contact the outside world.
This combined with widespread verbal and physical
abuse, extremely long working hours, a lack of
adequate rest days and non-payment, under-payment
or delayed payment of wages shows how easily substandard
working conditions can turn into working
situations tantamount to forced labour.
Some domestic workers were forced to work with
other workers in other businesses, and some didn't
have any choice in the type of jobs they performed.
Some domestic workers worked for free for extended
periods of time as a result of their debt bondage
to employers or recruiters. As "live-in" workers,
employers often expected domestic workers to be
available to work at all times.
Migrant workers can't freely change employers
since they lack control over their documentation
as examined previously in greater depth. Domestic
workers, like other workers, have the right to hold
onto their original ID card. However, only half of
the registered domestic workers manage to keep hold
of their original card.
Socio-cultural values and attitudes of employers often
play a role in justifying control over domestic workers'
freedom of movement. Employers don't recognise
that they have no right to keep hold of their workers'
documents. Employers may be well-meaning and do
this in the name of "protecting" domestic workers
from dangers outside the household, but such
"protection" violates the workers' basic rights to
freedom of movement...
4.2 Legal status and registration
Possession of legal working documents can partly
protect domestic workers from harassment and
reduce the risk of arrest or detention while they are
in Thailand. However, it has been found that even
registered migrant workers continue to live in fear
of deportation.
The majority of both employers and domestic
workers have positive attitudes toward Thai policy
on registration. Despite this fact, it was pointed out
that the registration process is too complicated, is not
clearly explained to those who need to understand it
and that the timeframe for registration is too short.
The registration policy, in turn, encourages employers
to take more control over, and diminish the rights
of their workers. Not only do many employers keep
their worker's original ID card, but some also refuse
to allow their domestic workers to register. Many
domestic workers can't afford the registration costs,
which can be equal to several months of their salary,
or end up being in debt to their employers who
pay for them. This becomes a reason for employers
holding their worker's original work permit. There
is no mention of whether or not the workers receive
their original ID back once the debt to an employer
is repaid in full.
Non-registered domestic workers are more likely
to face a greater degree of oppression in terms of
constraints on leaving their employment, and with
regard to payment and days off permitted than
registered migrant workers...
4.3 Working conditions
The risk of labour exploitation is high in light of the
fact that the majority of domestic workers don't know
about their working conditions until they arrive at
the home of their employer. Employers determine
working and payment conditions. A third of domestic
workers have to do both household chores and work
relating to the employer's business. According to the
Thai LPA (1998), this means they should no longer
be referred to as "domestic workers", and they should
be protected under Thai labour law.
Almost all (98%) the domestic workers surveyed
worked more than a standard eight-hour day. About
two thirds work more than 14 hours a day. It is worth
noting that they have to be available for work at any
time, whether it is inconvenient or not, based on the
needs of the employer.
In general, the amount earned by a manual worker
varies depending on the number of hours worked, but
this is not the case among migrant domestic workers.
Migrant domestic workers earn less than workers in
other sectors. About 40% receive a monthly salary of
less than 1,000 baht, while only 11% receive more
than 3,000 baht per month. This is well below the
Thai national standard minimum wage, with most
Thais earning at least 4,500 baht a month depending
on their workplace. Nobody involved refers to
overtime payments.
The situation is even worse when considering that
only a small proportion (7-17%) of domestic workers
receive regular weekly, monthly or annual leave.
Younger and unregistered domestic workers, on
average, work longer hours, receive lower pay and
receive less or no regular day off.
Employers perpetuate a number of myths to justify
the long working hours, lack of regular days off
and low wages of domestic workers. Firstly, it is
widely thought that domestic workers are able to
relax while employers are not at home. The current
study debunks this myth since many domestic
workers were overworked, working in more than one
workplace, with many different tasks to do and rarely
any time alone in the house. The second myth is that
domestic workers are able to take rest days whenever
they want. Most domestic workers were unable to
take leave and didn't receive the minimum number
of annual days off, to do so would risk them losing
their job or having their pay reduced...
4.4 Child domestic labour
In-depth interviews were held with two extremely
young domestic workers, aged 9 and 10. In the
survey of domestic workers, 20% were aged under
18. Employers suggested they like to hire children
as domestic workers because they are easy to control,
more obedient and diligent. Recruiters cited similar
reasons for recruiting children. Domestic work is
sometimes seen as work that is considered more
"appropriate" for children, however, child domestic
workers worked longer hours under worse conditions
for lower wages, in a "worst form" of child labour under
ILO Convention 182.
Employers indicated in the in-depth interviews that
they treat migrant domestic workers, particularly
child domestic workers, as family members. Child
domestic workers also pointed out that they are often
seen as part of the family. While this may sound warm
and friendly, in fact it can increase the children's
vulnerability to abuse. Child domestic workers
may be treated worse since they can't complain or
resist because they feel they are facing a "family"
obligation. Moreover, it becomes more difficult for
outsiders to intervene in "family" matters...
4.5 Support mechanisms
Since domestic workers are isolated in their employers'
residences they lack the usual mechanisms of family
and friends as support mechanisms for work-related
problems. Recruiters, who are sometimes relatives or
friends of the migrant, offer a key support structure
for domestic workers as they live in Thailand, have
the ability to visit the domestic workers regularly
and speak the same languages. Recruiters at least
offer domestic workers some contact with the outside
world and may be a starting point for possible future
interventions.
As live-in migrant domestic workers, contact with
the outside world is limited. However, mobile phones
now help many workers feel less isolated so they can
talk to other people, even if they can't meet with
them. The migrant domestic workers express their
willingness to meet and share their experiences with
others. And some of them are interested in studying
or continuing their studies in order to create a better
future for themselves. |
| Language: | | English, Thai |
| Source/publisher: | | International Labour Organisation |
| Format/size: | | pdf (English - 314K; Thai - 312K) |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://www.ilo.org/public/english/region/asro/bangkok/child/trafficking/downloads/vol2-domestic-tha... |
| Date of entry/update: | | 03 May 2008 |
|
| Title: | | The Mekong Challenge - Underpaid, Overworked and Overlooked: The realities of young migrant workers in Thailand: Vol. 2 (3) - The Fishing Sector |
| Date of publication: | | 13 December 2006 |
| Description/subject: | | Conclusions:
4.1 Indications of labour exploitation
The findings clearly show that being forced to work
is not uncommon in the fishing sector. About a fifth
of migrants have either previously experienced being
forced to work or are currently being forced to work.
Migrants working on fishing boats, female workers in
fish processing and children tend to experience forced
labour more than male workers in fish processing
and adult workers in general. The findings show
that employment aboard fishing vessels often means
working in extremely poor conditions, far worse than
those in the fish processing sector. It is no surprise
that migrant workers who are being forced to work
are more likely to end up working aboard fishing
boats. Being undocumented makes migrants even
more vulnerable to forced labour.
Physical and verbal abuse by employers is common
in the fishing sector, and alarmingly this seems to be
more commonly faced by child workers (aged under
15). While migrants work under poor conditions,
almost half of them feel they can't leave their job
because of certain constraints, mostly relating to fear
of arrest by the police. Migrants under 15 years of age
pointed to such constraints to a greater degree than
adult migrants. Somewhat surprisingly, registered
migrants feel there are more constraints preventing
them from leaving their current employment than
unregistered migrants. About two fifths of registered
migrants fear arrest by the authorities if they leave
their job. This implies that being registered does not
help all migrants feel any safer.
The fact that up to two thirds of registered migrants
do not have control over their documents explains
in part why registered migrants are still worried
about getting arrested. Keeping hold of the originals
of migrants' documents not only reflects a means
through which employers can prevent workers from
switching jobs, but it also highlights employers'
ignorance of the right migrants have to hold onto
their own documents. Some employers who keep
migrants' documents openly said they did not want
migrants to act, "as if they were Thai nationals who
could independently go anywhere, or leave their jobs
if they are not happy with them". This clearly shows
that many employers feel migrants should not be
treated the same as Thai nationals. It is consistent
with the results from the survey, which show that only
half of the employers surveyed agree that migrants
should have the same rights as Thai workers...
4.2 Legal status and registration
A migrant worker's legal status does not fully
guarantee his or her safety from exploitation at
the destination, however, it does, to a large extent,
reduce the possible scope of exploitation. Being
undocumented, for example, appears to increase the
chance that a migrant worker would be exploited at
work.
Studies reveal that compared to registered migrants,
unregistered (undocumented) migrant workers
tend to receive lower wages, work for longer hours,
start work earlier and have less rest time than their
documented counterparts. A far higher proportion of
migrants employed on fishing boats are unregistered
than those employed in fish processing. They live
and work in vulnerable conditions party because of
their undocumented status.
Although both employers and migrants in general
have positive attitudes regarding registration,
there are a number of difficulties. Migrants cross
the border into Thailand all the time, however,
the registration period is fixed. Therefore, hiring
undocumented migrants is still common since
employers need to hire workers and migrants are
readily available to work, no matter what their
legal status happens to be. Although arranging for
registration is the employers' responsibility, some
employers seem to be ignoring this important step.
As for migrants, it is not clear whether migrants
are fully aware that this step is the responsibility of
their employers. Nevertheless, knowing their rights
and the employer's responsibility does not guarantee
that migrants' rights will be fulfilled as the migrant
workers are unlikely to act without strong support
from the Thai government...
4.3 Working conditions
Most migrants work in very poor conditions. They
work for 12 hours on average, start working early,
even before 4 am on days when there is a heavy
workload, and almost half only get half an hour or
less break time per day. While almost 80% have
regular days off per month, less than a tenth are paid
for these days off. Given the nature of the work in
the fishing sector, it is understandable that some
migrants may need to start working very early,
however, working such long hours should be deemed
unacceptable, as should night work for children.
About a fifth of migrants work over 15 hours a day,
which is intolerable for a normal person.
As well as long working hours, evidently the minimum
wage is not commonly applied when hiring migrant
workers. In addition, if migrant labourers work for
more than eight hours a day, this does not guarantee
they receive wages at a rate above the minimum.
More than half the migrant workers who work for
more than eight hours a day still receive less than
the minimum wage. Migrant workers employed on
fishing boats receive particularly low rates of pay.
Most jobs for migrant workers in the fishing sector
are insecure due to variable work schedules and pay
methods, such as profit-based systems or piece rates.
Most migrant workers are treated the same as casual
workers with no benefits.
Migrants employed on fishing boats clearly work
in inferior conditions, in nearly all aspects, when
compared with migrants employed in fish processing.
Jobs on fishing boats are less attractive than in fish
processing factories because the nature of work is
tough, dangerous and it is lonely being far away
from family. Fishing boat employers explained that
they often had to take desperate steps to try and
recruit workers, despite offering incentives, such
as payments in advance. Despite such incentives,
it still seems as though jobs aboard fishing vessels
are the "last resort" for migrant workers. In light of
this, migrants working aboard fishing vessels may
be those who have nowhere else to go, or those who
have fewer job opportunities, such as unregistered
migrants or child workers. This could easily force
these workers into more vulnerable situations than
other migrant workers...
4.4 Child labour
Most of the children in this survey seem to be working
under the "worst forms" of child labour. Work on
fishing boats by its very nature may be considered a
worst form and therefore should not be performed by
children under the age of 17 years in accordance with
ILO Convention 182.
In fish processing, where children work for long hours
or start before 6am, this might also be considered
a worst form of child labour. Otherwise, under
regulated conditions, children aged 15 and over
may work in fish processing factories. Addressing
the worst forms of child labour in the fishing sector
needs an immediate response. Migrants under the
age of 15 made up 15% of the fishing sample despite
the fact that this contravenes Thai labour law (and
the ILO Convention 138 on Minimum Age which
Thailand has ratified).
Although very few employers openly admit they prefer
to employ children, employers implicitly expressed
a preference to hire children because they are fast
workers, obedient and cheaper than adult migrants.
While employers see the benefits of hiring younger
migrants, they do not fully see the responsibilities.
Some employers do not view child workers as "real"
workers, but more as children simply helping out
their parents. However, the migrant survey clearly
shows children are not simply acting in support roles.
In fishing, children are working even longer hours
than adult workers whilst receiving less support and
lower pay...
4.5 Support mechanisms
At destination, family and relatives are central
support figures for most migrants, this is especially
the case for child workers and migrants employed in
fish processing. Migrants employed on board fishing
boats depend more on their workmates and friends
and less on family members and relatives. This is due
to the unique physical environment of working on
fishing boats and spending long periods at sea.
Attaining a better education may help reduce the risk
for migrants of being trafficked. However, migrant
children have few prospects to attend school while
working in Thailand given their long daily working
hours. Very few migrants currently attend school
and less than a fifth of migrants reported that their
employers permit child workers to attend school.
In Thailand, part of a solution to address the
isolation facing migrants has been for NGOs to tap
into and strengthen migrants' sense of community.40
However, very few migrants working in the fishing
sector currently participate in any type of group in
their community. Encouraging migrants to be part
of a community organization might be worth further
exploration because most migrants express an interest
in joining a group or club, particularly with regard
to the subject of health issues. |
| Language: | | English, Thai |
| Source/publisher: | | International Labour Organisation |
| Format/size: | | pdf (English - 524K; Thai - 554K) |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://www.ilo.org/public/english/region/asro/bangkok/child/trafficking/downloads/vol2-fishing-thai... |
| Date of entry/update: | | 03 May 2008 |
|
| Title: | | The Mekong Challenge - Underpaid, Overworked and Overlooked: The realities of young migrant workers in Thailand: Vol. 2 (4) - The Manufacturing Sector |
| Date of publication: | | 13 December 2006 |
| Description/subject: | | Conclusions:
4.1 Indications of labour exploitation
While there are few outright cases of forced labour,
10% of migrant workers in manufacturing feel
the fact their employer holds their documents is a
constraint preventing them from leaving their job,
while 9% feel the threat of the employer reporting
them to the authorities also acts as a constraint
preventing them from leaving their job...
4.2 Working conditions
The most common form of abuse of migrant workers
employed in manufacturing is working extremely
long hours. A total of 7% of migrant workers have
faced physical abuse from their employers.
The average migrant worker employed in
manufacturing is paid only about half of what
they are entitled to when considering the standard
minimum wages under the LPA and according to the
time they actually work. Migrant workers often feel
unable to bargain with their employers effectively or
even know whom to contact to inform them about
their rights at work because they do not speak Thai.
Employers' associations and officials should address
the issue of language barriers faced by migrants.
Many employers do not take responsibility for
workers who are badly injured on the job on the
basis that the worker does not have a contract of
employment. A major concern and challenge for the
labour movement concerning migrant workers is the
fact that they are not permitted to form unions, and
in effect it is difficult for them to join Thai unions
or to see the value in joining Thai unions which
currently do not protect migrant workers' rights...
4.3 Legal status/Registration
Employers highlighted a number of problems with
the registration process, including the fact that
officers responsible for the registration process are
ill-prepared and the number of available officers is
insufficient. The registration period of one year is
viewed as not being long enough. Dissemination
of information about the registration process by the
Ministry of Labour is not sufficient. Employers waste
a lot of their time and their workers' time going
through the registration process. Many migrant
workers continue to fear harassment or be actually
harassed by the police even though they have a
valid work permit. Employers faced corrupt police
officers and in some cases paid up to 10,000 baht per
undocumented migrant they hire to police officers in
order to avoid prosecution...
4.4 Support mechanisms
Many migrant workers are less likely than Thais to
access state-healthcare services due to their isolation,
language barriers and a lack of information. |
| Language: | | English, Thai |
| Source/publisher: | | International Labour Organisation |
| Format/size: | | pdf (English - 289K; Thai - 301K) |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://www.ilo.org/public/english/region/asro/bangkok/child/trafficking/downloads/vol2-manufacturin... |
| Date of entry/update: | | 03 May 2008 |
|
| Title: | | The Mekong Challence - Working Day and Night: The Plight of Migrant Child Workers in Mae Sot, Thailand |
| Date of publication: | | 2006 |
| Description/subject: | | "Migrant children in Mae Sot are faced with excessive
working hours, lack of time off, and unhealthy
proximity to dangerous machines and chemicals.
They also endure the practice of debt bondage and the
systematic seizure of their identification documents.
Indeed many of these children in Mae Sot can most
accurately be described as enduring the "worst forms
of child labour, prohibited by the International Labour Organization's Convention No. 182 - a Convention that the Royal Thai Government ratified in
February, 2001.
These child workers reported that they were virtually forced to remain at the factory due to restrictions placed
on their movements by factory owners, and by threats of arrest and harassment by police and other officials
if they were stopped outside the factory gates. Put succinctly, Mae Sot has perfected a system where children
are literally working day and night, week after week, for wages that are far below the legal minimum wage,
to the point of absolute exhaustion..." |
| Author/creator: | | Philip S. Robertson Jr., Editor |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | International Labour Organisation |
| Format/size: | | pdf (4.45MB) |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://www.ilo.org/public/english/region/asro/bangkok/child/trafficking/downloads/workingdayandnigh... |
| Date of entry/update: | | 04 April 2007 |
|
| Title: | | Migrant Children in Difficult Circumstances in Thailand |
| Date of publication: | | 1999 |
| Description/subject: | | * Summary of report;
* Chapter 1: Migrant Children in Thailand - a Result of Globalisation...
* Chapter 2: Migrant Child Labor in Thailand...
* Chapter 3: Migrant Children in Prostitution in Thailand...
* Chapter 4: Migrant Street Children in Thailand:
* Indicators of Migrant Children in Thailand;
* Links to organisations working with Migrant Children in Thailand. |
| Author/creator: | | Premjai Vungsiriphisal, Siwaporn Auasalung, Supang Chantavanich |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | The Asian Research Center For Migration (ARCM), Chulalongkorn University, Bangkok, Thailand. |
| Format/size: | | pdf (147.99 KB) |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://books168.com/migrant-children-in-mae-sot-pdf.html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 17 July 2010 |
|
-
Construction workers
Individual Documents
| Title: | | New Work, but Old Complaints |
| Date of publication: | | December 2005 |
| Description/subject: | | Many Burmese migrant workers have landed new jobs in reconstruction work in southwest Thailand, having survived the tsunami. But old moans of low pay and rights abuses remain...
"Myint Win relaxes under a coconut palm on a beach in southwest Thailand, enjoying the sea breeze. But he’s not on holiday. Like hundreds of other Burmese in the area, he’s a migrant worker in the army of construction workers beavering to rebuild resorts in areas flattened by the December 26, 2004, tsunami, claiming more than 5,000 lives. Myint Win is just taking a lunch break.
The 49-year-old construction worker is on Ban Thantawan beach in Phang Nga province’s Khao Lak area. Beaches in the province were among the worst hit when the tsunami struck. The grim sound of sirens and the sight of bodies littering coastal areas have now been replaced by the hum of reconstruction and new hotels and resorts rising from the debris.
Burmese workers like Myint Win, a tractor driver back home, who were also out of work in the tsunami’s immediate aftermath, have found new jobs in the rebuilding frenzy to put southern resorts back on the tourist map. But they still complain of low pay and some human rights abuses because their migrant status leaves them vulnerable. “By and large, we have all been cheated,” one complains..." |
| Author/creator: | | Aung Lwin Oo |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "The Irrawaddy" Vol. 13, No. 12 |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 01 May 2006 |
|
-
Domestic workers
-
Domestic Workers from Burma
Individual Documents
| Title: | | Domestic workers in Thailand: their situation, challenges and the way forward |
| Date of publication: | | January 2010 |
| Description/subject: | | "...over the past 10 years there has been an increasing number of migrant
workers who have been recruited to do domestic work in the Thai households.
Despite the demand for and contribution of domestic workers in the larger economy and general
social good, domestic work is neither well recognized in the Thai society nor well protected by the
Thai labour law. Domestic work is regarded as a form of informal sector work which has limited
labour protection and social security coverage. The majority of migrant domestic workers are not
only more vulnerable to labour and other form of exploitation than Thai domestic workers, but they
also have little access to most of the labour protection under the Thai labour law.
This report reviews and analyzes the situation of both Thai and non-Thai domestic workers in
Thailand, in particular those working in private households, by drawing on existing reliable
information. It hopes to bring out key issues and recommendations which can contribute to the
advocacy efforts of ILO and its partners in Thailand in their campaign on decent work for domestic
workers..." |
| Author/creator: | | Vachararutai (Jan) Boontinand |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | International Labour Organisation |
| Format/size: | | pdf (374K) |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/groups/public/---asia/---ro-bangkok/documents/publication/wcms_120274.pdf
http://www.ilo.org/asia/whatwedo/publications/lang--en/docName--WCMS_120274/index.htm |
| Date of entry/update: | | 30 January 2010 |
|
| Title: | | The Mekong Challenge - Underpaid, Overworked and Overlooked : The realities of young migrant workers in Thailand (Volume 1) |
| Date of publication: | | 13 December 2006 |
| Description/subject: | | "...Thailand has emerged as the number one destination in cross-border trafficking of children and women. Many children and young women from Myanmar, Cambodia and Lao PDR migrate to Thailand in search of better life. Often their journey leads them to a life of exploitation. A significant percent of these young migrants work in four employment sectors; agriculture, fishing boats and fish processing, manufacturing and domestic work. While they become an integral part of the economy, they remain invisible and face exploitation. Exploitation is widespread and ranges from non-payment or underpayment of wages, a requirement to work excessive hours sometimes involving the use of hazardous equipment - to even more serious violations of forced labour and trafficking..." |
| Author/creator: | | Elaine Pearson, Sureeporn Punpuing, Aree Jampaklay, Sirinan Kittisuksathit, Aree Prohmmo |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Mekong Sub-regional Project to Combat Trafficking in Women and Children, ILO |
| Format/size: | | pdf (English - 2.5MB, 5.23 MB) |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://www.humantrafficking.org/uploads/publications/underpaid-eng-volume1.pdf |
| Date of entry/update: | | 12 April 2008 |
|
| Title: | | The Mekong Challenge - Underpaid, Overworked and Overlooked: The realities of young migrant workers in Thailand: Vol. 2 (2) - The Domestic Work Sector |
| Date of publication: | | 13 December 2006 |
| Description/subject: | | Conclusions:
4.1 Indications of labour exploitation
The findings illustrate a clear pattern of severe
labour exploitation of migrant domestic workers,
and in various cases evidence of forced labour.
Domestic workers surveyed in Chiang Mai and Mae
Sot reported being locked in the house unable to
readily communicate or contact the outside world.
This combined with widespread verbal and physical
abuse, extremely long working hours, a lack of
adequate rest days and non-payment, under-payment
or delayed payment of wages shows how easily substandard
working conditions can turn into working
situations tantamount to forced labour.
Some domestic workers were forced to work with
other workers in other businesses, and some didn't
have any choice in the type of jobs they performed.
Some domestic workers worked for free for extended
periods of time as a result of their debt bondage
to employers or recruiters. As "live-in" workers,
employers often expected domestic workers to be
available to work at all times.
Migrant workers can't freely change employers
since they lack control over their documentation
as examined previously in greater depth. Domestic
workers, like other workers, have the right to hold
onto their original ID card. However, only half of
the registered domestic workers manage to keep hold
of their original card.
Socio-cultural values and attitudes of employers often
play a role in justifying control over domestic workers'
freedom of movement. Employers don't recognise
that they have no right to keep hold of their workers'
documents. Employers may be well-meaning and do
this in the name of "protecting" domestic workers
from dangers outside the household, but such
"protection" violates the workers' basic rights to
freedom of movement...
4.2 Legal status and registration
Possession of legal working documents can partly
protect domestic workers from harassment and
reduce the risk of arrest or detention while they are
in Thailand. However, it has been found that even
registered migrant workers continue to live in fear
of deportation.
The majority of both employers and domestic
workers have positive attitudes toward Thai policy
on registration. Despite this fact, it was pointed out
that the registration process is too complicated, is not
clearly explained to those who need to understand it
and that the timeframe for registration is too short.
The registration policy, in turn, encourages employers
to take more control over, and diminish the rights
of their workers. Not only do many employers keep
their worker's original ID card, but some also refuse
to allow their domestic workers to register. Many
domestic workers can't afford the registration costs,
which can be equal to several months of their salary,
or end up being in debt to their employers who
pay for them. This becomes a reason for employers
holding their worker's original work permit. There
is no mention of whether or not the workers receive
their original ID back once the debt to an employer
is repaid in full.
Non-registered domestic workers are more likely
to face a greater degree of oppression in terms of
constraints on leaving their employment, and with
regard to payment and days off permitted than
registered migrant workers...
4.3 Working conditions
The risk of labour exploitation is high in light of the
fact that the majority of domestic workers don't know
about their working conditions until they arrive at
the home of their employer. Employers determine
working and payment conditions. A third of domestic
workers have to do both household chores and work
relating to the employer's business. According to the
Thai LPA (1998), this means they should no longer
be referred to as "domestic workers", and they should
be protected under Thai labour law.
Almost all (98%) the domestic workers surveyed
worked more than a standard eight-hour day. About
two thirds work more than 14 hours a day. It is worth
noting that they have to be available for work at any
time, whether it is inconvenient or not, based on the
needs of the employer.
In general, the amount earned by a manual worker
varies depending on the number of hours worked, but
this is not the case among migrant domestic workers.
Migrant domestic workers earn less than workers in
other sectors. About 40% receive a monthly salary of
less than 1,000 baht, while only 11% receive more
than 3,000 baht per month. This is well below the
Thai national standard minimum wage, with most
Thais earning at least 4,500 baht a month depending
on their workplace. Nobody involved refers to
overtime payments.
The situation is even worse when considering that
only a small proportion (7-17%) of domestic workers
receive regular weekly, monthly or annual leave.
Younger and unregistered domestic workers, on
average, work longer hours, receive lower pay and
receive less or no regular day off.
Employers perpetuate a number of myths to justify
the long working hours, lack of regular days off
and low wages of domestic workers. Firstly, it is
widely thought that domestic workers are able to
relax while employers are not at home. The current
study debunks this myth since many domestic
workers were overworked, working in more than one
workplace, with many different tasks to do and rarely
any time alone in the house. The second myth is that
domestic workers are able to take rest days whenever
they want. Most domestic workers were unable to
take leave and didn't receive the minimum number
of annual days off, to do so would risk them losing
their job or having their pay reduced...
4.4 Child domestic labour
In-depth interviews were held with two extremely
young domestic workers, aged 9 and 10. In the
survey of domestic workers, 20% were aged under
18. Employers suggested they like to hire children
as domestic workers because they are easy to control,
more obedient and diligent. Recruiters cited similar
reasons for recruiting children. Domestic work is
sometimes seen as work that is considered more
"appropriate" for children, however, child domestic
workers worked longer hours under worse conditions
for lower wages, in a "worst form" of child labour under
ILO Convention 182.
Employers indicated in the in-depth interviews that
they treat migrant domestic workers, particularly
child domestic workers, as family members. Child
domestic workers also pointed out that they are often
seen as part of the family. While this may sound warm
and friendly, in fact it can increase the children's
vulnerability to abuse. Child domestic workers
may be treated worse since they can't complain or
resist because they feel they are facing a "family"
obligation. Moreover, it becomes more difficult for
outsiders to intervene in "family" matters...
4.5 Support mechanisms
Since domestic workers are isolated in their employers'
residences they lack the usual mechanisms of family
and friends as support mechanisms for work-related
problems. Recruiters, who are sometimes relatives or
friends of the migrant, offer a key support structure
for domestic workers as they live in Thailand, have
the ability to visit the domestic workers regularly
and speak the same languages. Recruiters at least
offer domestic workers some contact with the outside
world and may be a starting point for possible future
interventions.
As live-in migrant domestic workers, contact with
the outside world is limited. However, mobile phones
now help many workers feel less isolated so they can
talk to other people, even if they can't meet with
them. The migrant domestic workers express their
willingness to meet and share their experiences with
others. And some of them are interested in studying
or continuing their studies in order to create a better
future for themselves. |
| Language: | | English, Thai |
| Source/publisher: | | International Labour Organisation |
| Format/size: | | pdf (English - 314K; Thai - 312K) |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://www.ilo.org/public/english/region/asro/bangkok/child/trafficking/downloads/vol2-domestic-tha... |
| Date of entry/update: | | 03 May 2008 |
|
| Title: | | The Mekong Challence - Working Day and Night: The Plight of Migrant Child Workers in Mae Sot, Thailand |
| Date of publication: | | 2006 |
| Description/subject: | | "Migrant children in Mae Sot are faced with excessive
working hours, lack of time off, and unhealthy
proximity to dangerous machines and chemicals.
They also endure the practice of debt bondage and the
systematic seizure of their identification documents.
Indeed many of these children in Mae Sot can most
accurately be described as enduring the "worst forms
of child labour, prohibited by the International Labour Organization's Convention No. 182 - a Convention that the Royal Thai Government ratified in
February, 2001.
These child workers reported that they were virtually forced to remain at the factory due to restrictions placed
on their movements by factory owners, and by threats of arrest and harassment by police and other officials
if they were stopped outside the factory gates. Put succinctly, Mae Sot has perfected a system where children
are literally working day and night, week after week, for wages that are far below the legal minimum wage,
to the point of absolute exhaustion..." |
| Author/creator: | | Philip S. Robertson Jr., Editor |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | International Labour Organisation |
| Format/size: | | pdf (4.45MB) |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://www.ilo.org/public/english/region/asro/bangkok/child/trafficking/downloads/workingdayandnigh... |
| Date of entry/update: | | 04 April 2007 |
|
| Title: | | Migrant Domestic Workers: From Burma to Thailand (short version) |
| Date of publication: | | 23 July 2005 |
| Description/subject: | | Abstract:
Millions of people from Burma have migrated into neighboring countries over the past decade.
Most have left their country in search of security and safety as a direct result of internal conflict
and militarization, severe economic hardship and minority persecution. This exodus represents
one of the largest migration flows in Southeast Asia.
Fearing persecution, the vast majority of those migrating from Burma find themselves desperate
to survive, obtaining work in underground and, often, illegal labor markets. The majority of those
fleeing Burma migrate to neighboring Thailand, where an estimated two million people from
Burma work in “3-D jobs” (dangerous, dirty and difficult). Although there is a growing
awareness of their isolation and vulnerability to labor exploitation and violence, there is little
data available documenting their realities. This results in the alienation of domestic workers and
perpetuates the disregard for their labor and basic rights.
This paper presents the findings of research proposed and implemented by members of the Shan
Women’s Action Network and the Karen Women’s Organization regarding girls and women who
have migrated from Burma into domestic work in Thailand. This paper focuses on the roots
causes of migration from Burma to Thailand, the harsh conditions in which foreign domestic
workers are employed and their inability to defend their most basic rights while they are in
Thailand, and lastly on their future aspirations.
Foreign domestic workers interviewed in this study described that the major cause of migration
were related to political and economic situations in Burma. The push-pull theory explains this
migration stream. In Thailand, the migrant domestic workers being expected to work on
demand, without agreed upon responsibilities or a written contract delineating working hours,
days off, accommodations, salaries, sick leave, care or pay. However, they had their dreams and
hopes of securing a better future for their families and themselves. In the recommendations,
roles of both Burma and Thai governments, NGOs and CBOs in helping establish appropriate
interventions to reduce the abuse, exploitation and trafficking of migrant domestic workers are
stated. The importance of recognizing domestic work as labor as well as the need to provide
protection for the domestic workers under national labor laws is emphasised in this study..." |
| Author/creator: | | Sureeporn Punpuing, Therese Caouette, Awatsaya Panam, Khaing Mar Kyaw Zaw |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Office of Population Research at Princeton University |
| Format/size: | | pdf (226K) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 04 May 2005 |
|
| Title: | | Migrant Domestic Workers: From Burma to Thailand (full version) |
| Date of publication: | | July 2004 |
| Description/subject: | | An important and well-researched report. “Millions of people from Burma1 have migrated into neighboring countries over the past
decade. Most have left their country in search of security and safety as a direct result of
internal conflict and militarization, severe economic hardship and minority persecution. This
exodus represents one of the largest migration flows in Southeast Asia. The minority people
of Burma make up the majority of those dislocated as a result of Burma's State Peace and
Development Council's (SPDC's) renewed commitment to eliminate ethnic militias and any
support for them in minority areas through forced labor and portering, as well as forced
relocation and arbitrary taxation, all of which leave the country's population, particularly the
minorities, extremely vulnerable.
Fearing persecution, the vast majority of those migrating from Burma find themselves
desperate to survive, obtaining work in underground and, often, illegal labor markets. The
majority of those fleeing Burma migrate to neighboring Thailand, where an estimated two
million people from Burma work in "3-D jobs" (dangerous, dirty and difficult), for pay well below
minimum wage. While clearly in need of assistance and protection, migrants from Burma have
a particularly difficult time exercising their rights in Thailand due to the Thai government's
policy of denying the majority of them refugee status. Living in perpetual fear of deportation,
migrants from Burma face abhorrent labor practices as a result of their illegal status, as well as
the lack of standardized working conditions and protection mechanisms.
It is estimated that well over one hundred thousand females from Burma are employed
as domestic workers in Thailand, though little information is available on the realities faced by
these women and girls. Although there is a growing awareness of their isolation and
vulnerability to labor exploitation and violence, there is little data available documenting their
realities. This results in the alienation of domestic workers and perpetuates the disregard for
their labor and basic rights. Consequently, neither migrants nor domestic workers (including
Thai citizens) have any official means of reporting or seeking redress to the grievances or
abuses they encounter in their jobs....” |
| Author/creator: | | Awatsaya Panam, Khaing Mar Kyaw Zaw, Therese Caouette, Sureeporn Punpuing |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Institute for Population and Social Research, Mahidol University, Thailand |
| Format/size: | | pdf (250 pages) |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://www.ibiblio.org/obl/docs3/Domestic_workers-ocr.pdf (3.23MB)
http://www.ibiblio.org/obl/docs3/Domestic_workers-textonly.pdf (1.2MB) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 20 November 2005 |
|
-
Factory workers
Individual Documents
| Title: | | Flexible Labor in the Thai-Burma Border Economy |
| Date of publication: | | 2007 |
| Description/subject: | | Capital Expansion
and Migrant Workers...
"...The research looks at the plight of Burmese migrant workers on the border between Thailand and Burma, in particular the town of Mae Sot. Mae Sot has become notorious for the amount, and severity of the human rights abuses. The research demonstrates that the changes to manufacturing, labour, and capital investment has led to a systematic erosion of labor rights. As argued in the thesis, labour rights are consistently sacrificed in order to attract and maintain investment, raising questions as to who are the primary beneficiaries of capitalist development. As Thailand and neighboring countries take further steps to increase border industrialization and development, labor standards are being pushed down both directly for the migrant workers employed in border industries, and often for domestic workers who are being forced to accept lower standards. The research examines the international economic context to the rise of Mae Sot as a manufacturing centre. It also looks at the groups involved in protecting workers rights, specifically the role of trade unions, and suggests that social and political organizing workers must be reignited in order to ensure their protection..." |
| Author/creator: | | Dennis Arnold |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Office of Human Rights Studies and Social Development, Faculty of Graduate Studies, Mahidol University (Human Rights in Asia Series) |
| Format/size: | | pdf (520K) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 16 April 2008 |
|
| Title: | | The Mekong Challenge - Underpaid, Overworked and Overlooked: The realities of young migrant workers in Thailand: Vol. 2 (4) - The Manufacturing Sector |
| Date of publication: | | 13 December 2006 |
| Description/subject: | | Conclusions:
4.1 Indications of labour exploitation
While there are few outright cases of forced labour,
10% of migrant workers in manufacturing feel
the fact their employer holds their documents is a
constraint preventing them from leaving their job,
while 9% feel the threat of the employer reporting
them to the authorities also acts as a constraint
preventing them from leaving their job...
4.2 Working conditions
The most common form of abuse of migrant workers
employed in manufacturing is working extremely
long hours. A total of 7% of migrant workers have
faced physical abuse from their employers.
The average migrant worker employed in
manufacturing is paid only about half of what
they are entitled to when considering the standard
minimum wages under the LPA and according to the
time they actually work. Migrant workers often feel
unable to bargain with their employers effectively or
even know whom to contact to inform them about
their rights at work because they do not speak Thai.
Employers' associations and officials should address
the issue of language barriers faced by migrants.
Many employers do not take responsibility for
workers who are badly injured on the job on the
basis that the worker does not have a contract of
employment. A major concern and challenge for the
labour movement concerning migrant workers is the
fact that they are not permitted to form unions, and
in effect it is difficult for them to join Thai unions
or to see the value in joining Thai unions which
currently do not protect migrant workers' rights...
4.3 Legal status/Registration
Employers highlighted a number of problems with
the registration process, including the fact that
officers responsible for the registration process are
ill-prepared and the number of available officers is
insufficient. The registration period of one year is
viewed as not being long enough. Dissemination
of information about the registration process by the
Ministry of Labour is not sufficient. Employers waste
a lot of their time and their workers' time going
through the registration process. Many migrant
workers continue to fear harassment or be actually
harassed by the police even though they have a
valid work permit. Employers faced corrupt police
officers and in some cases paid up to 10,000 baht per
undocumented migrant they hire to police officers in
order to avoid prosecution...
4.4 Support mechanisms
Many migrant workers are less likely than Thais to
access state-healthcare services due to their isolation,
language barriers and a lack of information. |
| Language: | | English, Thai |
| Source/publisher: | | International Labour Organisation |
| Format/size: | | pdf (English - 289K; Thai - 301K) |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://www.ilo.org/public/english/region/asro/bangkok/child/trafficking/downloads/vol2-manufacturin... |
| Date of entry/update: | | 03 May 2008 |
|
| Title: | | EXPLOITATION IN GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAINS: BURMESE MIGRANT WORKERS IN MAE SOT, THAILAND |
| Date of publication: | | September 2005 |
| Description/subject: | | CONCLUSIONS
As outlined, the situation in Mae Sot makes it difficult for organisations to operate effectively in support of Burmese workers. In mid-2004 there were no Thailand-based organisations working specifically on labour issues in Tak. As we have shown, migrant workers are in a vulnerable situation and greater organisational and protection efforts are needed. This organisational and political weakness is in stark contrast to that of employers who enjoy the support of the state. This imbalance makes it difficult for workers to organise to protect or promote their rights. The handful of Burmese organisations attempting to assist workers is limited because of their problematic legal status in Thailand and the intimidation prevents them from operating without fear of reprisals.
Structural factors promote the exploitation and human rights violations of Burmese migrant labourers. Burmese leave Burma due to political oppression and socio-economic hardship, and subsequently have a high threshold for the difficulties they endure in Thailand. Thai authorities and employers, regardless of nationality, are eager to exploit this vulnerability in their effort to maximise profits. A lack of corporate social responsibility and adherence to corporate codes of conduct means workers at the bottom of the supply chain, in places such as Mae Sot, produce textiles and garments and other products for developed country markets in a state of constant exploitation and oppression. It is obvious that Burmese migrant workers in Thailand face a myriad of human rights issues in Thailand and Burma. Denying the freedom to organise effectively undermines any attempts by migrant workers to improve their situation.
The policy of the Thai government towards Burmese refugees and migrants is changing. Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra’s government has forged closer economic and political ties with the Burmese junta and this has involved an increasingly hard-line stance towards Burmese migrants and refugees. Some million and a half Burmese migrant workers in Thailand are now stuck between one the most brutal military dictatorships in the world, and a Thai government intent on maintaining good relations. While the Thai government trumpets “constructive engagement,” there is no doubt that the government’s attitude is driven by business interests.
It is worth noting that the traditional gap between migrant support organisations and workers, and Thai labour organisations has been reduced over the last year or so. This, in combination with greater advocacy for migrant rights – by Thailand’s Human Rights Commission, international and global trade unions, academics in Thailand and the region, governments and human and labour rights organisations both in the region and internationally – is creating space and the potential for greater transparency and respect for labour rights and adherence to labour laws and standards. It may enhance the ability of migrant workers to organise and improve work conditions, but the struggle will still be a long and difficult one. |
| Author/creator: | | Dennis Arnold, Kevin Hewison |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Journal of Contemporary Asia, Vol. 35 No. 3, 2005, pp. 319-340. |
| Format/size: | | pdf (145K) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 08 October 2005 |
|
| Title: | | The Price of Exploitation |
| Date of publication: | | October 2004 |
| Description/subject: | | "Thai factory owners face huge claims after judge rules for Burmese migrants.
About 200 Thai factories employing migrant Burmese workers are braced to meet compensation claims amounting to many millions of dollars following the success of a legal action brought by 18 employees in Thailand’s Tak Province.
The Burmese migrants were awarded a total of 1,170,000 baht (US $29,250) in compensation for unpaid back wages owed by their employer, the Nut Knitting Ltd Partnership in Mae Sot, on the Thai-Burmese border.
The Tak Labor Court decision was hailed as a “landmark” by Moe Swe, director of the Mae Sot-based Yaung Chi Oo Workers Association, which backs Burmese migrant workers in their fight with Thai employers for proper wages and working conditions..." |
| Author/creator: | | Colin Baynes |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "The Irrawaddy" Vol. 12, No. 9 |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 11 November 2004 |
|
| Title: | | The Situation of Burmese Migrant Workers in Mae Sot, Thailand |
| Date of publication: | | September 2004 |
| Description/subject: | | CONCLUSION:
As briefly outlined, the situation in Mae Sot makes it difficult for Burmese worker
support organisations to operate effectively. As late as mid-2004 there were no
Thailand-based labour organisations or trade unions working specifically on
labour or trade union rights in Tak with an office and staff located there on a full
time basis. The workers themselves are in an extremely vulnerable situation
and greater organisational and protection efforts are needed. This
organisational and political weakness is in stark contrast to that of the
authorities, police and employers. This imbalance makes it difficult for workers
to organise to protect and promote their rights. The handful of Burmese
organisations attempting to assist workers is limited because of their
problematic legal status in Thailand and the intense pressure preventing them
from operating without fear of reprisal.
Structural factors promote the gross exploitation and human rights violations of
Burmese migrant labourers in Mae Sot. Burmese leave Burma due to political
oppression and socio-economic hardship, and subsequently have a high
threshold for difficulties they endure in Thailand. Thai authorities and employers,
regardless of nationality, are eager to exploit this vulnerability for windfall profits.
A lack of corporate social responsibility and adherence to corporate codes of
conduct means workers at the bottom of the supply chain, in places such as
Mae Sot, produce textiles and garments and other products for Northern
markets in a state of acute vulnerability.
It’s obvious that migrant workers in Thailand, particularly the Burmese, bear a
lot of pressure from nearly every direction, both in Burma and Thailand. A
myriad of human rights are abused in both systematic and random ways.
Denying the right to freedom of association and right to organise effectively
pulls out any attempts by migrant workers to improve their situation at the roots.
The policy of the Thai government towards Burmese refugees and migrants is
in the process of changing, for better or worse remains to be seen. Prime
Minister Thaksin Shinawatra’s forging of closer economic and political ties with
the Burmese government has resulted in an increasingly hard-line stance by
Thailand towards Burmese migrant workers and refugees, many of the latter
have become migrant workers. Some million and a half Burmese migrant
workers in Thailand are now stuck between one the most brutal military
dictatorship in the world, and a Thai government intent on good relations with
them, with an eye on increased revenue for businessmen operating in Thailand,
and for Thai business operating in Burma.
It is worth noting that the traditional gap between migrant support organisations
and workers, and Thai unions and labour organisations has been reduced over
the last year or so. This, in combination with greater advocacy for migrant
rights – by Thailand’s Human Rights Commission, international and global trade
unions, academics in Thailand and the region, governments and human and
labour rights organisations both in the region and internationally – is creating space and the potential for greater transparency and respect for labour rights
and adherence to labour laws and standards. It also enhances the ability of
migrant workers to organise and improve work conditions." |
| Author/creator: | | Dennis Arnold |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | The Southeast Asia Research Centre (SEARC) of the City University of Hong |
| Format/size: | | pdf (294K) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 08 October 2005 |
|
-
Fishery workers
Individual Documents
| Title: | | Masters of the Sea |
| Date of publication: | | September 2010 |
| Description/subject: | | Thailand is one of the world’s major fish-exporting countries, but it is Burmese fishermen who keep the industry alive...
"Aung Than is no ordinary fisherman. At 33, he is already a veteran of the seas. His years of hard work and commitment to his job have earned him the position of “yay shuu,” or master, of the Thai-owned vessel on which he and his fellow Burmese crew members make their living in the Andaman Sea.
As the most experienced and highly qualified member of his ship’s crew, he earns 10,000 baht (US $310) a month—about three times the basic salary of a Burmese fisherman working in Thailand, and 10 times what he would make in his native Burma.
Thailand’s fishing industry is kept afloat by a massive influx of migrant labor from neighboring Burma. Both on the ships and in the fish-processing plants, Burmese make up the majority of workers, doing jobs shunned by Thais. Fishermen are in especially high demand, working long hours for low wages, often risking life and limb to keep consumers around the world supplied with seafood..." |
| Author/creator: | | Kyaw Thein Kha |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "The Irrawaddy" Vol. 18, No. 9 |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 08 September 2010 |
|
| Title: | | Sickening’ Film on Plight of Burmese Migrant Fishermen |
| Date of publication: | | November 2008 |
| Description/subject: | | A documentary film showing how Burmese seamen aboard Thai fishing boats are abused, beaten and even murdered is now available for viewing on the Internet...
"The 10-minute film, titled “Abandoned, not Forgotten,” was released on the official Web site of the International Transport Workers’ Federation (ITWF), whose General Secretary, David Cockcroft, described it as “a sometimes sickening but very necessary addition to the evidence that many Burmese citizens forced to flee their country are being appallingly treated.”..." |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | International Transportworkers' Federation via "The Irrawaddy" Vol. 16, No. 11 |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://www.itfglobal.org/fisheries/film.cfm http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=deCo_ZBSk-U |
| Date of entry/update: | | 16 November 2008 |
|
| Title: | | The Mekong Challenge - Underpaid, Overworked and Overlooked: The realities of young migrant workers in Thailand: Vol. 2 (3) - The Fishing Sector |
| Date of publication: | | 13 December 2006 |
| Description/subject: | | Conclusions:
4.1 Indications of labour exploitation
The findings clearly show that being forced to work
is not uncommon in the fishing sector. About a fifth
of migrants have either previously experienced being
forced to work or are currently being forced to work.
Migrants working on fishing boats, female workers in
fish processing and children tend to experience forced
labour more than male workers in fish processing
and adult workers in general. The findings show
that employment aboard fishing vessels often means
working in extremely poor conditions, far worse than
those in the fish processing sector. It is no surprise
that migrant workers who are being forced to work
are more likely to end up working aboard fishing
boats. Being undocumented makes migrants even
more vulnerable to forced labour.
Physical and verbal abuse by employers is common
in the fishing sector, and alarmingly this seems to be
more commonly faced by child workers (aged under
15). While migrants work under poor conditions,
almost half of them feel they can't leave their job
because of certain constraints, mostly relating to fear
of arrest by the police. Migrants under 15 years of age
pointed to such constraints to a greater degree than
adult migrants. Somewhat surprisingly, registered
migrants feel there are more constraints preventing
them from leaving their current employment than
unregistered migrants. About two fifths of registered
migrants fear arrest by the authorities if they leave
their job. This implies that being registered does not
help all migrants feel any safer.
The fact that up to two thirds of registered migrants
do not have control over their documents explains
in part why registered migrants are still worried
about getting arrested. Keeping hold of the originals
of migrants' documents not only reflects a means
through which employers can prevent workers from
switching jobs, but it also highlights employers'
ignorance of the right migrants have to hold onto
their own documents. Some employers who keep
migrants' documents openly said they did not want
migrants to act, "as if they were Thai nationals who
could independently go anywhere, or leave their jobs
if they are not happy with them". This clearly shows
that many employers feel migrants should not be
treated the same as Thai nationals. It is consistent
with the results from the survey, which show that only
half of the employers surveyed agree that migrants
should have the same rights as Thai workers...
4.2 Legal status and registration
A migrant worker's legal status does not fully
guarantee his or her safety from exploitation at
the destination, however, it does, to a large extent,
reduce the possible scope of exploitation. Being
undocumented, for example, appears to increase the
chance that a migrant worker would be exploited at
work.
Studies reveal that compared to registered migrants,
unregistered (undocumented) migrant workers
tend to receive lower wages, work for longer hours,
start work earlier and have less rest time than their
documented counterparts. A far higher proportion of
migrants employed on fishing boats are unregistered
than those employed in fish processing. They live
and work in vulnerable conditions party because of
their undocumented status.
Although both employers and migrants in general
have positive attitudes regarding registration,
there are a number of difficulties. Migrants cross
the border into Thailand all the time, however,
the registration period is fixed. Therefore, hiring
undocumented migrants is still common since
employers need to hire workers and migrants are
readily available to work, no matter what their
legal status happens to be. Although arranging for
registration is the employers' responsibility, some
employers seem to be ignoring this important step.
As for migrants, it is not clear whether migrants
are fully aware that this step is the responsibility of
their employers. Nevertheless, knowing their rights
and the employer's responsibility does not guarantee
that migrants' rights will be fulfilled as the migrant
workers are unlikely to act without strong support
from the Thai government...
4.3 Working conditions
Most migrants work in very poor conditions. They
work for 12 hours on average, start working early,
even before 4 am on days when there is a heavy
workload, and almost half only get half an hour or
less break time per day. While almost 80% have
regular days off per month, less than a tenth are paid
for these days off. Given the nature of the work in
the fishing sector, it is understandable that some
migrants may need to start working very early,
however, working such long hours should be deemed
unacceptable, as should night work for children.
About a fifth of migrants work over 15 hours a day,
which is intolerable for a normal person.
As well as long working hours, evidently the minimum
wage is not commonly applied when hiring migrant
workers. In addition, if migrant labourers work for
more than eight hours a day, this does not guarantee
they receive wages at a rate above the minimum.
More than half the migrant workers who work for
more than eight hours a day still receive less than
the minimum wage. Migrant workers employed on
fishing boats receive particularly low rates of pay.
Most jobs for migrant workers in the fishing sector
are insecure due to variable work schedules and pay
methods, such as profit-based systems or piece rates.
Most migrant workers are treated the same as casual
workers with no benefits.
Migrants employed on fishing boats clearly work
in inferior conditions, in nearly all aspects, when
compared with migrants employed in fish processing.
Jobs on fishing boats are less attractive than in fish
processing factories because the nature of work is
tough, dangerous and it is lonely being far away
from family. Fishing boat employers explained that
they often had to take desperate steps to try and
recruit workers, despite offering incentives, such
as payments in advance. Despite such incentives,
it still seems as though jobs aboard fishing vessels
are the "last resort" for migrant workers. In light of
this, migrants working aboard fishing vessels may
be those who have nowhere else to go, or those who
have fewer job opportunities, such as unregistered
migrants or child workers. This could easily force
these workers into more vulnerable situations than
other migrant workers...
4.4 Child labour
Most of the children in this survey seem to be working
under the "worst forms" of child labour. Work on
fishing boats by its very nature may be considered a
worst form and therefore should not be performed by
children under the age of 17 years in accordance with
ILO Convention 182.
In fish processing, where children work for long hours
or start before 6am, this might also be considered
a worst form of child labour. Otherwise, under
regulated conditions, children aged 15 and over
may work in fish processing factories. Addressing
the worst forms of child labour in the fishing sector
needs an immediate response. Migrants under the
age of 15 made up 15% of the fishing sample despite
the fact that this contravenes Thai labour law (and
the ILO Convention 138 on Minimum Age which
Thailand has ratified).
Although very few employers openly admit they prefer
to employ children, employers implicitly expressed
a preference to hire children because they are fast
workers, obedient and cheaper than adult migrants.
While employers see the benefits of hiring younger
migrants, they do not fully see the responsibilities.
Some employers do not view child workers as "real"
workers, but more as children simply helping out
their parents. However, the migrant survey clearly
shows children are not simply acting in support roles.
In fishing, children are working even longer hours
than adult workers whilst receiving less support and
lower pay...
4.5 Support mechanisms
At destination, family and relatives are central
support figures for most migrants, this is especially
the case for child workers and migrants employed in
fish processing. Migrants employed on board fishing
boats depend more on their workmates and friends
and less on family members and relatives. This is due
to the unique physical environment of working on
fishing boats and spending long periods at sea.
Attaining a better education may help reduce the risk
for migrants of being trafficked. However, migrant
children have few prospects to attend school while
working in Thailand given their long daily working
hours. Very few migrants currently attend school
and less than a fifth of migrants reported that their
employers permit child workers to attend school.
In Thailand, part of a solution to address the
isolation facing migrants has been for NGOs to tap
into and strengthen migrants' sense of community.40
However, very few migrants working in the fishing
sector currently participate in any type of group in
their community. Encouraging migrants to be part
of a community organization might be worth further
exploration because most migrants express an interest
in joining a group or club, particularly with regard
to the subject of health issues. |
| Language: | | English, Thai |
| Source/publisher: | | International Labour Organisation |
| Format/size: | | pdf (English - 524K; Thai - 554K) |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://www.ilo.org/public/english/region/asro/bangkok/child/trafficking/downloads/vol2-fishing-thai... |
| Date of entry/update: | | 03 May 2008 |
|
| Title: | | Trawling Troubles |
| Date of publication: | | November 2004 |
| Description/subject: | | Life on a Thai fishing boat isn’t all plain sailing for Burmese crews...
"When 29-year old Win San signed on as a boatswain on a Thai fishing trawler he looked forward to a profitable voyage in the Andaman Sea off the coast of his native Burma. Instead, he ended up in an Indonesian jail, accused of illegally fishing in that country’s waters.
Saphan Plah wharf (upgrading) where Burmese enter into Ranong.
Win San was held for one month, then deported to Thailand. It could have been worse—the skipper of the boat, his assistant and chief engineer, all Thais, were sentenced to two years in prison.
Win San’s experience is typical of the hazards faced by Burmese migrants who work in the fishing industry based in the southern Thai port Ranong, just across the Pachan River from Burma’s Victoria Point (Kawthaung)..." |
| Author/creator: | | Aung Lwin Oo |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "The Irrawaddy" Vol. 12, No. 10 |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 31 January 2005 |
|
-
Migrant workers from Burma by origin
-
Migrant workers from Shan State
Individual Documents
| Title: | | The Grass is Greener |
| Date of publication: | | September 2009 |
| Description/subject: | | Despite the difficulties and challenges facing Shan migrants seeking work in Thailand, their numbers are increasing...
"I feel my life in Thailand is more secure than in Burma. It is easier to make a living here,” said Sam Htun, a 56-year-old Shan construction worker, who said he left Burma because of oppression, dangerous working conditions and dismal economic circumstances..." |
| Author/creator: | | Saw Yan Naing |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "The Irrawaddy" Vol. 17, No. 6 |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 19 January 2010 |
|
-
Other categories of migrant workers
Individual Documents
| Title: | | The Road To Riches? |
| Date of publication: | | July 2004 |
| Description/subject: | | "Burma’s young Chinese look abroad for a brighter future.
Forty years ago, the grandfather of Si Si, a young Chinese woman living in Rangoon, migrated to Burma from China’s Guangdong Province, in search of a better future and perhaps prosperity.
Chinese New Year in Rangoon.
Today, 24-year old Si Si is planning to take up the same search, but outside Burma. She sees her immediate professional future in a developed country such as Singapore..." |
| Author/creator: | | Htet Win |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "The Irrawaddy" vol. 12, No. 7 |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 11 November 2004 |
|
| Title: | | Come to Singapore And Leave Your Views Behind |
| Date of publication: | | August 2002 |
| Description/subject: | | "...The only type of foreigner more unwelcome in Singapore than an illegal migrant is an exiled dissident. Singapore’s intolerance of political dissent is a fact of life that is not lost on anyone who lives here. .." |
| Author/creator: | | Neil Lawrence |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "The Irrawaddy" Vol. 10, No. 6, July-August 2002 |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 03 June 2003 |
|
-
Policies towards Burmese migrant workers
Individual Documents
| Title: | | Hard Labor |
| Date of publication: | | May 2008 |
| Description/subject: | | Many Burmese invest hope and money to get work permits for Malaysia, only to find themselves exploited...
"“I regret coming to Malaysia,” murmured Ko Shwe. “I feel afraid here. The only thing I want now is to go home.”
A farmer from Sittwe in western Burma, Ko Shwe left his home last year after the protests against rising fuel prices sparked a national uprising. Faced with economic misery in Burma, Ko Shwe joined the thousands of Burmese—especially those from rural areas—migrating to foreign countries to earn a living. Just seven days after starting work at a factory in Kuala Lumpur, he lost his right hand while working with an electric lathe.
Construction workers at a site in Kuala Lumpur. Typically, migrant workers face exploitation by employers and deportation by authorities.
(Photo: AFP)
Hiding his injury self-consciously, Ko Shwe spoke about his plan to return to Burma after he receives some compensation from his employer. However, as his work permit has not yet been approved, he is not confident of getting anything—not even reimbursement for his hospital bill.
The ongoing economic decline in Burma has led to an outflow of laborers to neighboring countries. While Thailand has the most open market for illegal foreign labor, countries such as Malaysia provide an opportunity for workers with passports who can apply for legal employment..." |
| Author/creator: | | Violet Cho |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "The Irrawaddy" Vol. 16, No. 5 |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 01 May 2008 |
|
| Title: | | Burmese Migrant Workers in Thailand: Policy and Protection |
| Date of publication: | | December 2001 |
| Description/subject: | | "It is estimated that the overall number of Burmese migrants in Thailand is somewhere in between 800,000 and one million.
Cross-border migration into Thailand has steadily increased in recent years. Since the 1960s, hundreds of thousands of Thais
have gone to work abroad. Refugees from Burma, Laos and Cambodia have since filled this labour shortage in Thailand.
However, many of them are undocumented, illegal workers and thus constitute the most vulnerable section of the work force.
As illegal non-citizens, they are least protected by a national legal system. The Thai Cabinet recently announced a new policy
on migrant workers..." |
| Author/creator: | | Darunee Paisanpanichkul |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "Legal Issues on Burma Journal" No. 10 (Burma Lawyers' Council) |
| Alternate URLs: | | The original (and authoritative) version of this article may be found in http://www.ibiblio.org/obl/docs/Legal_Issues_on%20Burma_Journal_10.pdf |
| Date of entry/update: | | 03 June 2003 |
|
| Title: | | Labor Pains |
| Date of publication: | | September 2001 |
| Description/subject: | | "The Thai government's latest resolution to control the growing migrant worker population lacks
resolve.
The Thai government is promising a "total solution" to the country's migrant worker population. But if
history is any guide, the new resolution looks just like the latest rendition of previously flawed policies. For
years Burmese migrants have fueled border industries with cheap labor, but with a recession looming the
Thai government is once again trying to tackle a problem that has caused previous administrations to
stumble.
Thai Labor Minister Dej Bunlong has said this latest registration scheme would benefit employers and
workers both. Bunlong said employers would no longer have to pay kickbacks to keep their workers from
being arrested and the workers would in turn benefit from both their legal standing and from the health
care coverage they would be entitled to under the new resolution. This is the first time the government
has offered to issue an unlimited number of work permits. Any worker who is at least eighteen years old
and who is living in Thailand before September 24th is eligible for a permit if they apply before the October
13th deadline..." |
| Author/creator: | | Tony Broadmoor |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "The Irrawaddy", Vol 9. No. 7, August-September 2001 |
| Format/size: | | pdf (89K) ; html |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://web.archive.org/web/20020628190739/www.irrawaddy.org/database/2001/vol9.7/labor.html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 03 June 2003 |
|
-
Seafarers
Individual Documents
| Title: | | Shoring up Burma’s Seamen |
| Date of publication: | | January 2003 |
| Description/subject: | | "From inside Burma, a job at sea might seem like a good career move, but many Burmese seamen are finding the voyage anything but smooth sailing.
When the Seafarers Union of Burma (SUB) and the Port Authority of Thailand Workers Union conducted a check of ships harbored in Bangkok last October, they found 18 Burmese crewmembers on board a Taiwanese vessel named the Timber Star with salaries well below International Labor Organization (ILO) standards.
"The ILO minimal standard wage is US $581 a month for a seaman," says Aung Thura, SUB’s assistant general secretary. "On the Timber Star the basic salary is $240, but from that, agents take an extra $100 to $150 for themselves," he adds. According to Aung Thura, three men on board the Timber Star took home only $50 a month.
"When we found out that the crew members weren’t getting ILO standard salaries, we asked the ship’s owner to pay them in full. But the ship had already left the port," he explains. The SUB is now calling on members from other affiliates of the International Transport Workers’ Federation (ITF) to join in an international strike against the owner of the Timber Star..." |
| Author/creator: | | Ko Thet |
| Language: | | English |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 03 June 2003 |
|
-
Sex workers
Individual Documents
| Title: | | The Sex-for-sale Trap - Why Burmese migrant women risk all to work in Thailand’s brothels. |
| Date of publication: | | November 2004 |
| Description/subject: | | "Thirty-year-old Ma Lay (not her real name) seems an unlikely commercial sex worker. Soberly dressed and well spoken, she talks with serious concern about her efforts to educate other women in the sex trade about the risks of contracting AIDS.
She is well qualified to lead an awareness campaign in the southern Thai town of Ranong, on the Burmese border. She has sold sex there for several years, sending money home to her family in Burma. She knows the scene well. And she is HIV-positive..." |
| Author/creator: | | Yeni |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "The Irrawaddy" Vol. 12, No. 10 |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 31 January 2005 |
|
| Title: | | Trafficking on the Thai-Burma Border |
| Date of publication: | | November 2004 |
| Description/subject: | | Informal Burmese networks supply teenaged girls to customers of Thailand’s commercial sex industry. |
| Author/creator: | | Colin Baynes |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "The Irrawaddy", Vol. 12, No. 10 |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 31 January 2005 |
|
| Title: | | NO STATUS: MIGRATION, TRAFFICKING & EXPLOITATION OF WOMEN IN THAILAND |
| Date of publication: | | 14 July 2004 |
| Description/subject: | | I. Executive Summary;
II. Introduction;
III. Thailand: Background.
IV. Burma: Background.
V. Project Methodology;
VI. Findings:
Hill Tribe Women and Girls in Thailand; Burmese Migrant Women and Girls in Thailand;
VII. Law and Policy â“ Thailand;
VIII. Applicable International Human Rights Law;
IX. Law and Policy â“ United States
X. Conclusion and Expanded Recommendations..."This study was designed to provide critical insight and
remedial recommendations on the manner in which
human rights violations committed against Burmese
migrant and hill tribe women and girls in Thailand render
them vulnerable to trafficking,2 unsafe migration,
exploitative labor, and sexual exploitation and, consequently,
through these additional violations, to
HIV/AIDS. This report describes the policy failures of
the government of Thailand, despite a program widely
hailed as a model of HIV prevention for the region.
Physicians for Human Rights (PHR) findings show that
the Thai government's abdication of responsibility for
uncorrupted and nondiscriminatory law enforcement
and human rights protection has permitted ongoing violations
of human rights, including those by authorities
themselves, which have caused great harm to Burmese
and hill tribe women and girls..." |
| Author/creator: | | Karen Leiter, Ingrid Tamm, Chris Beyrer, Moh Wit, Vincent Iacopino,. Holly Burkhalter, Chen Reis. |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Physicians for Human Rights |
| Format/size: | | pdf (853K) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 19 July 2004 |
|
| Title: | | One Way Ticket |
| Date of publication: | | January 2004 |
| Description/subject: | | Whether seeking a spouse or a job, there is no turning back for many Burmese women who journey to China
By /Ruili, China...
"Nandar faces a tough time in Ruili, a Chinese town close to Burma. She has no money and lives in a small, messy room in an apartment building that doubles as a brothel. But her face shows no fear. She looks like many of the Burmese girls who hang out in Ruili at night, their faces painted a ghostly white, sporting tight skirts or jeans, and soliciting men along a busy, shadowy street corner in the town center. But Nandar is not among them—yet..." |
| Author/creator: | | Naw Seng |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "The Irrawaddy" Vol. 12, No. 1 |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 07 March 2004 |
|
| Title: | | Wooing Women Workers |
| Date of publication: | | October 2003 |
| Description/subject: | | "Crackdowns on Burmese migrants in Thailand push many women into the flesh trade...
When 22-year-old Sandar Kyaw first arrived in Thailand from Burma two months ago, she worked 12-hour days, sewing clothing in one of the many garment factories around the border town of Mae Sot. Now she sits in a hot, dimly lit room in a brothel, watching TV with her co-workers, and waiting for a man to pay 500 baht (US $12.50) for one hour of sex with her.
With six younger siblings and her parents struggling to make ends meet in Rangoon, making money is her main priority. "I want to save 10,000 baht and go home," she says. Since factory wages for illegal Burmese migrants average roughly 2,000 baht per month, saving such a sum on her sewing wages would have taken months. When her friend suggested they leave the factory for the more lucrative brothel, Sandar Kyaw agreed. Since she retains half her hourly fee, just one customer a day can net her three times her factory wage..." |
| Author/creator: | | Kevin R. Manning |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "The Irrawaddy" Vol 11, No. 8 |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://www.irrawaddymedia.com/article.php?art_id=3128 |
| Date of entry/update: | | 06 December 2003 |
|
| Title: | | MIGRATION & TRAFFICKING OF WOMEN & GIRLS (Chapter from "Gathering Strength") |
| Date of publication: | | January 2002 |
| Description/subject: | | OVERVIEW;
RESTRICTION ON WOMEN'S FREEDOM OF MOVEMENT;
REGIONAL MIGRATION;
TRAFFICKING;
SEX WORK;
DEPORTATION;
ACTIONS TO COMBAT TRAFFICKING;
FINDINGS & RECOMMENDATIONS. |
| Author/creator: | | Brenda Belak |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Images Asia |
| Format/size: | | PDF (567K) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 03 June 2003 |
|
| Title: | | "MIGRATING WITH HOPE": Burmese Women Working in Thailand and The Sex Industry |
| Date of publication: | | July 1997 |
| Description/subject: | | "...This report, "Migrating With Hope: Burmese Women Working In Thailand and
The Sex Industry" attempts to present and highlight the needs, interests, and
realities of undocumented migrant women from Burma working as sex-workers
in Thailand. We look at the lives of women in Burma, the migration processes,
processes of entry into the sex-industry, and factors which govern women's wellbeing
or suffering during the time of migration in Thailand. The authors hope
that the documentation presented will provide useful information to prospective
migrants from Burma. We also hope that it can be used to instigate programmes
to protect the rights of and to provide the necessary services for undocumented
migrant workers, and by doing this, prevent more Burmese women from being
exploited. This report is written in the knowledge that women can become
empowered to make informed choices about their lives. It is also hoped that this
report will provide the general public with information not only about Burmese
migrant women, but also about the situation of undocumented migrant workers
who flee from Burma, a country ruled by a military regime..." |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Images Asia |
| Format/size: | | pdf (284K) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 19 May 2005 |
|
| Title: | | A MODERN FORM OF SLAVERY: |
| Date of publication: | | August 1993 |
| Description/subject: | | A substantial and important report.
""Lin Lin" was thirteen years old when she was recruited by an agent for work in Thailand. Her father took $480 from the agent with the understanding that his daughter would pay the loan back out of her earnings. The agent took "Lin Lin" to Bangkok, and three days later she was taken to the Ran Dee Prom brothel. "Lin Lin" did not know what was going on until a man came into her room and started touching her breasts and body and then forced her to have sex. For the next two years, "Lin Lin" worked in various parts of Thailand in four different brothels, all but one owned by the same family. The owners told her she would have to keep prostituting herself until she paid off her father's debt. Her clients, who often included police, paid the owner $4 each time. If she refused a client's demands, she was slapped and threatened by the owner. She worked every day except for the two days off each month she was allowed for her menstrual period. Once she had to borrow money to pay for medicine to treat a painful vaginal infection. This amount was added to her debt. On January 18, 1993 the Crime Suppression Division of the Thai police raided the brothel in which "Lin Lin" worked, and she was taken to a shelter run by a local non-governmental organization. She was fifteen years old, had spent over two years of her young life in compulsory prostitution, and tested positive for the human immunodeficiency virus or HIV.
"Lin Lin" is just one of thousands of Burmese women and girls who have been trafficked and sold into what amounts to female sexual slavery in Thailand. In the last two years, Thai NGOs estimate that at a minimum, some twenty thousand Burmese women and girls are suffering Lee's fate, or worse, and that ten thousand new recruits come in every year. They are moved from one brothel to another as the demand for new faces dictates, and often end up being sent back to Burma after a year or two to recruit their own successors..." |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Asia Watch and the Women's Rights Project (Human Rights Watch) |
| Format/size: | | html (394K) |
| Date of entry/update: | | 03 June 2003 |
|
-
Women migrant workers
Individual Documents
| Title: | | Problem Pregnancies |
| Date of publication: | | July 2008 |
| Description/subject: | | Low paid jobs for Burmese migrants are plentiful—but no babies, please...
MAE SOT, Thailand — "A pregnant woman sits on her hospital bed, loudly pleading for an abortion. In the same ward, another woman gazes with devotion at her own newly born child.
A third woman attracts my attention because of her dark eyes, wide and innocent, in a pale face, damp with sweat. Ma Khaing is her name. She says she also wanted to abort her baby, by taking the traditional purgative kay thi pan.
The herbal concoction only made her ill. The unborn baby was unharmed, although 23-year-old Ma Khaing was clearly not pleased to hear the news from medical staff at Dr Cynthia Maung’s Mae Tao clinic in the Thai-Burmese border town of Mae Sot. She looked downcast as a medic told her the baby would survive.
Ma Khaing earns 160 baht (US $5) a day working on a sugar cane plantation near Mae Sot. Pregnancy and the prospect of an infant to care for pose a real threat to her livelihood—and I’m not surprised when she says: “I don’t want the baby. I want to work and save money.”
Ma Khaing’s story is typical, according to Mae Tao staffer Naw Pine Mu. She has seen many abortion cases in her five years at the clinic.
“All are migrant women, working in the factories or in the sugar cane fields,” Naw Pine Mu says. Pregnancy and motherhood cost them their jobs and push them back into poverty..." |
| Author/creator: | | Aye Chan Myate |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | "The Irrawaddy" Vol. 16, No. 7 |
| Format/size: | | html |
| Date of entry/update: | | 15 July 2008 |
|
| Title: | | Caught Between Two Hells |
| Date of publication: | | December 2007 |
| Description/subject: | | The Report Highlights the Situation of Women Migrant Workers in Thailand and China...Executive Summary:
Ten BWU researchers eondueted 149 in-depth interviews with migrant women and girl workers in Chiang Mai, Mae Sot, Ranong (Thailand) and Rulli (China) between November 2006-March 2007. Women working in diverse areas of work, ethnicity and age were asked to participate in the research so that the report could represent a wide range of experiences... The research highlights the atrocious day-to-day working conditions and human rights abuses encountered by migrant women and girls working in irregular situations and provides insight into the occupational hazards and harms migrants from Burma face in Thailand and China. The interviews were designed to provide women workers with a much-needed opportunity to speak their mind and assert their own "voice" regarding their work, a power that was often denied in their host countries...
The research has showed that:
. Migrant women and girl workers from Burma have very limited
work opportunities in their host countries due to their irregular
status and are often relegated to working in so-called 3Ds jobs (dirty,
dangerous and demeaning) with little or no labor rights. . Migrant women and girl workers are doubly marginalized and highly
vulnerable to abuses of their human rights due to both their lack of
legal status and their gender. Security concerns for migrant women and girl workers are grave as
they regularly experience threats of sexual harassment and violence
while working in host countries...
The BWU strongly urges the SPDC and governments of the host countries to consider migrant workers' needs and basic human rights. BWU insists that international human rights law be upheld and states work to protect migrants working in irregular settings, by protecting their human and labour rights, and by providing channels for redress when they are abused. |
| Language: | | English |
| Source/publisher: | | Burmese Women's Union |
| Format/size: | | pdf (2.74MB) |
| Alternate URLs: | | http://www.ibiblio.org/obl/docs4/Caught_between_two_hells.pdf |
| Date of entry/update: | | 05 January 2008 |
|
|
|